Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Can lambda functions be templated?

People also ask

Can lambda be templated?

Lambda-expressions are not allowed in unevaluated expressions, template arguments, alias declarations, typedef declarations, and anywhere in a function (or function template) declaration except the function body and the function's default arguments.

Can lambdas be Inlined?

Calls of the lambda are translated to direct calls to its operator() and can therefore be inlined.

Can lambda be Constexpr?

Visual Studio 2017 version 15.3 and later (available in /std:c++17 mode and later): A lambda expression may be declared as constexpr or used in a constant expression when the initialization of each data member that it captures or introduces is allowed within a constant expression.

Are lambdas functors?

Lambdas are basically just syntactic sugar that implement functors (NB: closures are not simple.) In C++0x, you can use the auto keyword to store lambdas locally, and std::function will enable you to store lambdas, or pass them around in a type-safe manner.


UPDATE 2018: C++20 will come with templated and conceptualized lambdas. The feature has already been integrated into the standard draft.


UPDATE 2014: C++14 has been released this year and now provides Polymorphic lambdas with the same syntax as in this example. Some major compilers already implement it.


At it stands (in C++11), sadly no. Polymorphic lambdas would be excellent in terms of flexibility and power.

The original reason they ended up being monomorphic was because of concepts. Concepts made this code situation difficult:

template <Constraint T>
void foo(T x)
{
    auto bar = [](auto x){}; // imaginary syntax
}

In a constrained template you can only call other constrained templates. (Otherwise the constraints couldn't be checked.) Can foo invoke bar(x)? What constraints does the lambda have (the parameter for it is just a template, after all)?

Concepts weren't ready to tackle this sort of thing; it'd require more stuff like late_check (where the concept wasn't checked until invoked) and stuff. Simpler was just to drop it all and stick to monomorphic lambdas.

However, with the removal of concepts from C++0x, polymorphic lambdas become a simple proposition again. However, I can't find any proposals for it. :(


C++11 lambdas can't be templated as stated in other answers but decltype() seems to help when using a lambda within a templated class or function.

#include <iostream>
#include <string>

using namespace std;

template<typename T>
void boring_template_fn(T t){
    auto identity = [](decltype(t) t){ return t;};
    std::cout << identity(t) << std::endl;
}

int main(int argc, char *argv[]) {
    std::string s("My string");
    boring_template_fn(s);
    boring_template_fn(1024);
    boring_template_fn(true);
}

Prints:

My string
1024
1

I've found this technique is helps when working with templated code but realize it still means lambdas themselves can't be templated.


In C++11, lambda functions can not be templated, but in the next version of the ISO C++ Standard (often called C++14), this feature will be introduced. [Source]

Usage example:

auto get_container_size = [] (auto container) { return container.size(); };

Note that though the syntax uses the keyword auto, the type deduction will not use the rules of auto type deduction, but instead use the rules of template argument deduction. Also see the proposal for generic lambda expressions(and the update to this).


In C++20 this is possible using the following syntax:

auto lambda = []<typename T>(T t){
    // do something
};

I am aware that this question is about C++11. However, for those who googled and landed on this page, templated lambdas are now supported in C++14 and go by the name Generic Lambdas.

[info] Most of the popular compilers support this feature now. Microsoft Visual Studio 2015 supports. Clang supports. GCC supports.