Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

What is the most notable difference between Jenkins and Hudson from an user perpective?

It is around 10 months now that Jenkins split off from Hudson.

When looking at the project homepages I am wondering what the differences between Hudson and Jenkins in the meantime really are. From the changelog I do not realy learn much. There are a bunch of changes and the major difference seems to be that Jenkins releases more often with less changes and Hudson less frequently, but then with more changes in a release.

Are there any notable differences yet? So are there things that make me as a developer needing a CI system more productive rather with the one or the other? Is one of them more stable than the other? Is there any difference yet that has nothing to do with politics around Oracle?

What is the most notable difference from your point of view?

like image 773
Ansgar Avatar asked Oct 10 '11 07:10

Ansgar


People also ask

What is the difference between Hudson and Jenkins?

There is no such difference between Hudson and Jenkins. Jenkins is actually the renamed version of Hudson. After disagreements between Oracle and Hudson creators, the latter decided that Hudson was to be forked and Jenkins CI.

When did Hudson become Jenkins?

Hudson–Jenkins split As a result, on January 11, 2011, a proposal was made to change the project name from "Hudson" to "Jenkins". The proposal was overwhelmingly approved by those that voted on January 29, 2011, creating the Jenkins project.

What is the difference between Jenkins and Maven?

A maven is a build tool designed to manage dependencies and the software lifecycle. It is also designed to work with plugins that allow users to add other tasks to the standard compile, test, package, install, deploy tasks. Jenkins is designed for the purpose of implementing Continuous Integration (CI).

What is difference between Jenkins and bamboo?

Bamboo is a commercial/licensed tool, while Jenkins is an open-source tool. As a result, Jenkins has a worldwide development community, whereas Bamboo has its specialized development team. Thus, any individual or professional involved in DevOps can download Jenkins.


1 Answers

One notable difference is that a big number of plugins moved to Jenkins. While you would still be able to use the old versions with Hudson, the newer versions depend on Jenkins already. Also new plugins are mostly created with dependencies on quite recent Jenkins versions, so you probably won't be able to use them without hassle on Hudson.

This will probably differ from plugin to plugin, some might be more compatible with Hudson than others, while still others provide versions for both tools. But if something does not work well with a plugin you will receive help easier if you use Jenkins.

EDIT: Here is an interesting link I found, not only providing some solid numbers on the different paths Jenkins and Hudson have taken, but also addressing the (non-)issue of IP that was mentioned in the other post here...

like image 105
pushy Avatar answered Oct 16 '22 05:10

pushy