What is the correct way to return an 'Invalid Value' type in C++, without the use of pointers?

Question

I often use -1 as the invalid value type when returning from a function, where the input yields incorrect output. For instance, writing an indexing function where the index is out of bounds, instead of throwing an exception, -1 can be returned. But when writing a function that has negative values as possible return types, this technique does not work. What is the correct way to return an invalid type value in such instances?

The technique I use mostly is to set the return type to be of type *int, and return a Pointer to NULL. But, that requires all return values to be of a pointer type, which seems like an extra overhead to the function. Is there an accepted standard for returning values in such cases?

Answer 1

In newer C++, I'd suggest using std::optional<>; if you don't yet have it, boost::optional<>.