When to use unsigned values over signed ones?

Question

When is it appropriate to use an unsigned variable over a signed one? What about in a for loop?

I hear a lot of opinions about this and I wanted to see if there was anything resembling a consensus.

for (unsigned int i = 0; i < someThing.length(); i++) {       SomeThing var = someThing.at(i);       // You get the idea.   } 

I know Java doesn't have unsigned values, and that must have been a concious decision on Sun Microsystems' part.

Answer 1

I was glad to find a good conversation on this subject, as I hadn't really given it much thought before.

In summary, signed is a good general choice - even when you're dead sure all the numbers are positive - if you're going to do arithmetic on the variable (like in a typical for loop case).

unsigned starts to make more sense when:

• You're going to do bitwise things like masks, or
• You're desperate to to take advantage of the sign bit for that extra positive range .

Personally, I like signed because I don't trust myself to stay consistent and avoid mixing the two types (like the article warns against).