Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

What's the difference between "update" and "update_idletasks"?

Tags:

From the effbot.org documentation, we have the following about the update function:

Processes all pending events, calls event callbacks, completes any pending geometry management, redraws widgets as necessary, and calls all pending idle tasks. This method should be used with care, since it may lead to really nasty race conditions if called from the wrong place (from within an event callback, for example, or from a function that can in any way be called from an event callback, etc.). When in doubt, use update_idletasks instead.

On the other hand, there's this about the update_idletasks function:

Calls all pending idle tasks, without processing any other events. This can be used to carry out geometry management and redraw widgets if necessary, without calling any callbacks.

As far as I understood, both call all pending idle tasks, complete any pending geometry management and redraw widgets as necessary. The only difference I see is that update processes all pending events and calls event callbacks. That's why we should not call update from within an even callback, I suppose.

However, I have seen examples where update_idletasks and update are used one after the other, and I can't understand the reason, since theoretically update does everything update_idletasks does.

What exactly are these pending events and the idle tasks the documentation is talking about? What are the differences and relations?

That being answered, in what real circumstances should I use update over update_idletasks? Concrete examples are also appreciated.

like image 343
nbro Avatar asked Mar 20 '15 03:03

nbro


People also ask

What does update () do in tkinter?

Python Tkinter Mainloop Update Update() method in mainloop in Python Tkinter is used to show the updated screen. It reflects the changes when an event occurs.

How do I use the progress bar in tkinter?

Use the ttk. Progressbar(container, orient, length, mode) to create a progressbar. Use the indeterminate mode when the program cannot accurately know the relative progress to display. Use the determinate mode if you know how to measure the progress accurately.

How do you use after in Python?

The after() method calls the callback function once after a delay milliseconds (ms) within Tkinter's main loop. If you don't provide the callback , the after() method behaves like the time. sleep() function. However, the after() method uses the millisecond instead of the second as the unit.


1 Answers

The only difference I see is that update processes all pending events and calls event callbacks. That's why we should not call update from within an even callback, I suppose.

You are correct on both accounts.

What are pending events? Events scheduled with after, mostly. And, as you also mentioned in your question, events that trigger a redraw.

The circumstances when you should use update over update_idletasks? Almost never. In all honesty, my pragmatic answer is "never call update unless calling update_idletasks doesn't do enough".

The important thing to remember is that update blocks until all events are processed. In effect, that means you have a mainloop nested inside a mainloop. It's never a good idea to have an infinite loop inside an infinite loop.

If you see examples where one is called after the other, you're looking at bad examples. Honestly, there's absolutely no reason whatsoever to do that. A lot of code I see calls update way more often than it ever should.

like image 72
Bryan Oakley Avatar answered Nov 19 '22 09:11

Bryan Oakley