Vulkan: What is the point of sType in vk*CreateInfo structs?

Question

In all of the create info structs (vk*CreateInfo) in the new Vulkan API, there is ALWAYS a .sType member. Why is this there if the value can only be one thing? Also the Vulkan specification is very explicit that you can only use vk*CreateInfo structs as parameters for their corresponding vkCreate* function. It seems a little redundant. I can see that if the driver was passing this struct straight to the GPU, you might need to have it (I did notice it is always the first member). But this seems like a really bad idea for the app to do it because if the driver did it, apps would be much less error prone, and prepending an int to a struct doesn't seems like an extremely computational inefficient operation. I just don't see why it exists.

TL;DR
    Why do the vk*CreateInfo structs have the .sType member?

Answer 1

They have one so that the pNext field actually works.

Yes, the API takes a struct with a proper C type, so both the caller and the receiver agree on what type that struct is. But especially nowadays, many such structs have linked lists of structures that provide additional information to the implementation. These extension structures (though many are core in Vulkan 1.1/2) are just like all other structures, with their own sType field.

These fields are crucial because the linked lists are built with pNext pointers... which are void*s. They have no set type. The way the implementation determines what a non-NULL pNext pointer points to is by examining the first 4 bytes stored there. This is the sType field; it allows the implementation to know what type to cast the pointer to.

Of course, the primary struct that an API takes doesn't strictly need an sType field, since its type is part of the API itself. However, there is a hypothetical reason to do so (it hasn't panned out in Vulkan releases).

A later version of Vulkan could expand on the creation of, for example, command buffer pools. But how would it do that? Well, they could add a whole new entrypoint: vkCreateCommandPool2. But this function would have almost the exact same signature as vkCreateCommandPool; the only difference is that they take different pCreateInfo structures.

So instead, all you have to do is declare a VkCommandPoolCreateInfo2 structure. And then declare that vkCreateCommandPool can take either one. How would the implementation tell which one you passed in?

Because the first 4 bytes of any such structure is sType. They can test that value. If the value is VK_STRUCTURE_TYPE_COMMAND_POOL_CREATE_INFO, then it's the old structure. If it's VK_STRUCTURE_TYPE_COMMAND_POOL_CREATE_INFO_2, then it's the new one.

Of course, as previously stated, this hasn't panned out; post-1.0 Vulkan versions opted to incorporate extension structs rather than replacing existing ones. But the option is there.