Menu
I am learning about XML Attributes from W3Schools.
The author mentions the following (emphasis mine):
XML Elements vs. Attributes
<person sex="female"> <firstname>Anna</firstname> <lastname>Smith</lastname> </person>
<person> <sex>female</sex> <firstname>Anna</firstname> <lastname>Smith</lastname> </person>In the first example sex is an attribute. In the last, sex is an element. Both examples provide the same information.
There are no rules about when to use attributes and when to use elements. Attributes are handy in HTML. In XML my advice is to avoid them. Use elements instead.
Avoid XML Attributes?
Some of the problems with using attributes are:
- attributes cannot contain multiple values (elements can)
- attributes cannot contain tree structures (elements can)
- attributes are not easily expandable (for future changes)
Attributes are difficult to read and maintain. Use elements for data. Use attributes for information that is not relevant to the data.
So is the view of the author a famous one, or is this the best practice in XML?
Should Attributes in XML be avoided?
W3Schools also mentioned the following (emphasis mine):
XML Attributes for Metadata
Sometimes ID references are assigned to elements. These IDs can be used to identify XML elements in much the same way as the ID attribute in HTML. This example demonstrates this:
<messages> <note id="501"> <to>Tove</to> <from>Jani</from> <heading>Reminder</heading> <body>Don't forget me this weekend!</body> </note> <note id="502"> <to>Jani</to> <from>Tove</from> <heading>Re: Reminder</heading> <body>I will not</body> </note> </messages>The ID above is just an identifier, to identify the different notes. It is not a part of the note itself.
What I'm trying to say here is that metadata (data about data) should be stored as attributes, and that data itself should be stored as elements.
517
Why should we avoid XML attributes. Attributes cannot contain multiple values but child elements can have multiple values. Attributes cannot contain tree structure but child element can. Attributes are not easily expandable.
Attributes are used to distinguish among elements of the same name, when you do not want to create a new element for every situation. Hence, the use of an attribute can add a little more detail in differentiating two or more similar elements.
An Attribute is something that is self-contained, i.e., a color, an ID, a name. An Element is something that does or could have attributes of its own or contain other elements.
Rules for XML attributes XML element can have more than one attributes. This we have already seen in the above example, where brand and category attributes are linked to the element <car>. 3. Attributes cannot contain duplicate multiple values.
Usage of attributes or elements is usually decided by the data you are trying to model.
For instance, if a certain entity is PART of the data, then it is advisable to make it an element. For example the name of the employee is an essential part of the employee data.
Now if you want to convey METADATA about data (something that provides additional information about the data) but is not really part of the data, then it is better to make it an attribute. For instance, lets say each employee has a GUID needed for back end processing, then making it an attribute is better.(GUID is not something that conveys really useful information to someone looking at the xml, but might be necessary for other purposes)
There is no rule as such that says something should be an attribute or a element.
Its not necessary to AVOID attributes at all costs..Sometimes they are easier to model, than elements. It really depends on the data you are trying to represent.
142
If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!
Donate Us With
