Porting Common Lisp code to Clojure

Question

How practical is it to port a Common Lisp application to Clojure? To be more specific, what features exist in Common Lisp that do not exist in Clojure, and would have to be re-written?

Answer 1

There's a list on clojure.org of differences between Clojure and other Lisps. Some other things I've noticed using Clojure:

• Idiomatic Clojure leans heavily toward immutable data structures. Anywhere you see SETF in CL may have to be changed in Clojure to take full advantage. (You always have the option of using mutable Java data structures in Clojure, but most people don't.)

• Clojure's multimethods are similar to CL's (arguably more powerful, because you can dispatch on things other than type) but a full-blown CLOS is not available in Clojure. Clojure uses struct instead, which is just a fancy hashmap. Java's OOP system is also available, of course. Some people are working on porting CLOS to Clojure but I'm not sure how far along those efforts are at this point.

• Clojure macros work slightly differently than CL macros when it comes to symbol/namespace resolution. I'm not sure if I understand well enough to elucidate the differences. You don't have to mess with gensyms quite as much in Clojure though, which is nice.

• Clojure doesn't have a condition system like CL's. You have only Java's try/catch/finally for exception handling.

• Clojure doesn't allow user-defined reader macros.

• Clojure doesn't have multiple return values. Destructuring in Clojure is very nice (supports lists, vectors, hash-maps, sets etc.) and it's built into more places than CL by default, so this is less of an issue than it could be.

Depending on the app and how it's written, it may be practical and straightforward to port from CL to Clojure, or it may be more practical to rewrite it from the ground up in a more functional, thread-safe way to fit better with Clojure style.

Answer 2

I don't have a specific answer, but I'd recommend these resources:

• Rich Hickey's two part talk Clojure for Lisp Programmers
• Stuart Halloway's work on translating the examples from Peter Seibel's Practical Common Lisp to Clojure.