`os.symlink` vs `ln -s`

Question

I need to create a symlink for every item of dir1 (file or directory) inside dir2. dir2 already exists and is not a symlink. In Bash I can easily achieve this by:

ln -s /home/guest/dir1/* /home/guest/dir2/ 

But in python using os.symlink I get an error:

>>> os.symlink('/home/guest/dir1/*', '/home/guest/dir2/') Traceback (most recent call last):   File "<stdin>", line 1, in <module> OSError: [Errno 17] File exist 

I know I can use subprocess and run ln command. I don't want that solution.

I'm also aware that workarounds using os.walk or glob.glob are possible, but I want to know if it is possible to do this using os.symlink.

Answer 1

os.symlink creates a single symlink.

ln -s creates multiple symlinks (if its last argument is a directory, and there's more than one source). The Python equivalent is something like:

dst = args[-1] for src in args[:-1]:     os.symlink(src, os.path.join(dst, os.path.dirname(src))) 

So, how does it work when you do ln -s /home/guest/dir1/* /home/guest/dir2/? Your shell makes that work, by turning the wildcard into multiple arguments. If you were to just exec the ln command with a wildcard, it would look for a single source literally named * in /home/guest/dir1/, not all files in that directory.

The Python equivalent is something like (if you don't mind mixing two levels together and ignoring a lot of other cases—tildes, env variables, command substitution, etc. that are possible at the shell):

dst = args[-1] for srcglob in args[:-1]:     for src in glob.glob(srcglob):         os.symlink(src, os.path.join(dst, os.path.dirname(src))) 

You can't do that with os.symlink alone—either part of it—because it doesn't do that. It's like saying "I want to do the equivalent of find . -name foo using os.walk without filtering on the name." Or, for that matter, I want to do the equivalent of ln -s /home/guest/dir1/* /home/guest/dir2/ without the shell globbing for me."

The right answer is to use glob, or fnmatch, or os.listdir plus a regex, or whatever you prefer.

Do not use os.walk, because that does a recursive filesystem walk, so it's not even close to shell * expansion.