Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Most efficient method of detecting/monitoring DOM changes?

I need an efficient mechanism for detecting changes to the DOM. Preferably cross-browser, but if there's any efficient means which are not cross browser, I can implement these with a fail-safe cross browser method.

In particular, I need to detect changes that would affect the text on a page, so any new, removed or modified elements, or changes to inner text (innerHTML) would be required.

I don't have control over the changes being made (they could be due to 3rd party javascript includes, etc), so it can't be approached from this angle - I need to "monitor" for changes somehow.

Currently I've implemented a "quick'n'dirty" method which checks body.innerHTML.length at intervals. This won't of course detect changes which result in the same length being returned, but in this case is "good enough" - the chances of this happening are extremely slim, and in this project, failing to detect a change won't result in lost data.

The problem with body.innerHTML.length is that it's expensive. It can take between 1 and 5 milliseconds on a fast browser, and this can bog things down a lot - I'm also dealing with a large-ish number of iframes and it all adds up. I'm pretty sure the expensiveness of doing this is because the innerHTML text is not stored statically by browsers, and needs to be calculated from the DOM every time it is read.

The types of answers I am looking for are anything from the "precise" (for example event) to the "good enough" - perhaps something as "quick'n'dirty" as the innerHTML.length method, but that executes faster.

EDIT: I should also point out that whilst it would be "nice" to detect the precise element that has been modified, it is not an absolute necessity - just the fact that there has been any change would be good enough. Hopefully this broadens people's responses. I'm going to investigate Mutation Events, but I still need a fallback for IE support, so any whacky, creative, outside-of-the-square ideas would be very welcome.

like image 894
Graza Avatar asked Mar 16 '10 18:03

Graza


People also ask

How do you detect DOM changes?

One way to watch for DOM changes in our JavaScript web app is to use the MutationObserver constructor. For instance, we can write: const observer = new MutationObserver((mutations, observer) => { console. log(mutations, observer); }); observer.

How does angular determine DOM changes?

Angular does not provide something built-in for that purpose. You can use MutationObserver to detect DOM changes.

Which method is triggered when an element is added to the DOM?

The actual answer is "use mutation observers" (as outlined in this question: Determining if a HTML element has been added to the DOM dynamically), however support (specifically on IE) is limited (http://caniuse.com/mutationobserver). So the actual ACTUAL answer is "Use mutation observers....


1 Answers

To bring this up to date, the DOM4 standard does away with Mutation Events and replaces them with Mutation Observers: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/MutationObserver

like image 167
zeveck Avatar answered Sep 22 '22 02:09

zeveck