implicit int and implicit declaration of functions with gcc compiler

Question

I read in the c99 Standard:

-remove implicit function declaration,

-remove implicit int.

But when I try to compile this code with gcc compiler in c99 mode using -pedantic

main(void){
    f(3);
    return 0;
}


int f(int a){
    ....
}

I expect 2 errors, but I just receive 2 warnings:

-warning: return type defaults to ‘int’

-warning: implicit declaration of function ‘f’.

Shouldn't them be errors in c99?

http://gcc.gnu.org/c99status.html In both situations there's written "done".

Thanks.

Answer 1

The C standard requires a diagnostic for any translation unit containing a violation of a syntax rule or constraint. It does not require such diagnostics to be fatal; the compiler is free to continue processing the source file. The behavior of the resulting executable, if any, is undefined. The standard makes no distinction between warnings and fatal errors.

(The only thing that requires a compiler to reject a source file is the #error directive.)

Conclusion: when compiling C, take warnings very seriously.

Answer 2

I don't believe the compiler is required to produce a fatal error. Use -Werror if you're concerned...