I don't really understand how modulus division works.
I was calculating 27 % 16
and wound up with 11
and I don't understand why.
I can't seem to find an explanation in layman's terms online. Can someone elaborate on a very high level as to what's going on here?
To calculate modulo division: Subtract the divisor from the dividend until the resultant is less than the divisor.
The modulus operator, sometimes also called the remainder operator or integer remainder operator works on integers (and integer expressions) and yields the remainder when the first operand is divided by the second. In Python, the modulus operator is a percent sign ( % ). The syntax is the same as for other operators.
The modulo division operator produces the remainder of an integer division. Syntax: If x and y are integers, then the expression: x % y. produces the remainder when x is divided by y. Return Value: If y completely divides x, the result of the expression is 0.
Answer: 1 mod 3 is 1. Let's find 1 mod 3. Explanation: 1 mod 3 equals 1, since 1/3 = 0 with a remainder of 1. To find 1 mod 3 using the modulus method, we first find the highest multiple of the divisor, 3 that is equal to or less than the dividend, 1.
Most explanations miss one important step, let's fill the gap using another example.
Given the following:
Dividend: 16
Divisor: 6
The modulus function looks like this:
16 % 6 = 4
Let's determine why this is.
First, perform integer division, which is similar to normal division, except any fractional number (a.k.a. remainder) is discarded:
16 / 6 = 2
Then, multiply the result of the above division (2
) with our divisor (6
):
2 * 6 = 12
Finally, subtract the result of the above multiplication (12
) from our dividend (16
):
16 - 12 = 4
The result of this subtraction, 4
, the remainder, is the same result of our modulus above!
The result of a modulo division is the remainder of an integer division of the given numbers.
That means:
27 / 16 = 1, remainder 11
=> 27 mod 16 = 11
Other examples:
30 / 3 = 10, remainder 0
=> 30 mod 3 = 0
35 / 3 = 11, remainder 2
=> 35 mod 3 = 2
The simple formula for calculating modulus is :-
[Dividend-{(Dividend/Divisor)*Divisor}]
So, 27 % 16 :-
27- {(27/16)*16}
27-{1*16}
Answer= 11
Note:
All calculations are with integers. In case of a decimal quotient, the part after the decimal is to be ignored/truncated.
eg: 27/16= 1.6875 is to be taken as just 1 in the above mentioned formula. 0.6875 is ignored.
Compilers of computer languages treat an integer with decimal part the same way (by truncating after the decimal) as well
Maybe the example with an clock could help you understand the modulo.
A familiar use of modular arithmetic is its use in the 12-hour clock, in which the day is divided into two 12 hour periods.
Lets say we have currently this time: 15:00
But you could also say it is 3 pm
This is exactly what modulo does:
15 / 12 = 1, remainder 3
You find this example better explained on wikipedia: Wikipedia Modulo Article
The modulus operator takes a division statement and returns whatever is left over from that calculation, the "remaining" data, so to speak, such as 13 / 5 = 2. Which means, there is 3 left over, or remaining from that calculation. Why? because 2 * 5 = 10. Thus, 13 - 10 = 3.
The modulus operator does all that calculation for you, 13 % 5 = 3.
modulus division is simply this : divide two numbers and return the remainder only
27 / 16 = 1 with 11 left over, therefore 27 % 16 = 11
ditto 43 / 16 = 2 with 11 left over so 43 % 16 = 11 too
Very simple: a % b
is defined as the remainder of the division of a
by b
.
See the wikipedia article for more examples.
I would like to add one more thing:
it's easy to calculate modulo when dividend is greater/larger than divisor
dividend = 5 divisor = 3
5 % 3 = 2
3)5(1
3
-----
2
but what if divisor is smaller than dividend
dividend = 3 divisor = 5
3 % 5 = 3 ?? how
This is because, since 5 cannot divide 3 directly, modulo will be what dividend is
I hope these simple steps will help:
20 % 3 = 2
20 / 3 = 6
; do not include the .6667
– just ignore it3 * 6 = 18
20 - 18 = 2
, which is the remainder of the moduloEasier when your number after the decimal (0.xxx) is short. Then all you need to do is multiply that number with the number after the division.
Ex: 32 % 12 = 8
You do 32/12=2.666666667
Then you throw the 2
away, and focus on the 0.666666667
0.666666667*12=8
<-- That's your answer.
(again, only easy when the number after the decimal is short)
27 % 16 = 11
You can interpret it this way:
16 goes 1 time into 27 before passing it.
16 * 2 = 32.
So you could say that 16 goes one time in 27 with a remainder of 11.
In fact,
16 + 11 = 27
An other exemple:
20 % 3 = 2
Well 3 goes 6 times into 20 before passing it.
3 * 6 = 18
To add-up to 20 we need 2 so the remainder of the modulus expression is 2.
The only important thing to understand is that modulus (denoted here by % like in C) is defined through the Euclidean division.
For any two (d, q)
integers the following is always true:
d = ( d / q ) * q + ( d % q )
As you can see the value of d%q
depends on the value of d/q
. Generally for positive integers d/q
is truncated toward zero, for instance 5/2 gives 2, hence:
5 = (5/2)*2 + (5%2) => 5 = 2*2 + (5%2) => 5%2 = 1
However for negative integers the situation is less clear and depends on the language and/or the standard. For instance -5/2 can return -2 (truncated toward zero as before) but can also returns -3 (with another language).
In the first case:
-5 = (-5/2)*2 + (-5%2) => -5 = -2*2 + (-5%2) => -5%2 = -1
but in the second one:
-5 = (-5/2)*2 + (-5%2) => -5 = -3*2 + (-5%2) => -5%2 = +1
As said before, just remember the invariant, which is the Euclidean division.
Further details:
Modulus division gives you the remainder of a division, rather than the quotient.
It's simple, Modulus operator(%) returns remainder after integer division. Let's take the example of your question. How 27 % 16 = 11? When you simply divide 27 by 16 i.e (27/16) then you get remainder as 11, and that is why your answer is 11.
Lets say you have 17 mod 6.
what total of 6 will get you the closest to 17, it will be 12 because if you go over 12 you will have 18 which is more that the question of 17 mod 6. You will then take 12 and minus from 17 which will give you your answer, in this case 5.
17 mod 6=5
Modulus division is pretty simple. It uses the remainder instead of the quotient.
1.0833... <-- Quotient
__
12|13
12
1 <-- Remainder
1.00 <-- Remainder can be used to find decimal values
.96
.040
.036
.0040 <-- remainder of 4 starts repeating here, so the quotient is 1.083333...
13/12 = 1R1, ergo 13%12 = 1.
It helps to think of modulus as a "cycle".
In other words, for the expression n % 12
, the result will always be < 12.
That means the sequence for the set 0..100
for n % 12
is:
{0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,0,[...],4}
In that light, the modulus, as well as its uses, becomes much clearer.
If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!
Donate Us With