Executing code in overloaded constructor prior to calling this()

Question

Say we have a class like this:

import java.net.URL
import xml._

class SearchData(xml: Node) {
  def this(url: URL) = this (XML.load(url))
}

and we want to execute some code prior to calling this (XML.load(url)) - say test it with try. One would expect that writing something like this would work:

class SearchData(xml: Node) {
  def this(url: URL) {
    try {
        this (XML.load(url))
    } catch {
      case _ => this(<results/>)
    }
  }
}

but it won't, because Scala requires that you make the call to this() the first statement in the overloaded constructor and in this case try becomes the first statement.

So what would be the solution to this problem?

Answer 1

def this(url: Url) = this(try {XML.load(url)} catch {case _ => <results/>})

More generally, the evaluation of the arguments has to happen before the constructor call, so you do that there (a block in scala is an expression, but write a routine, typically written in the companion object, if it is going to be too long). What you cannot do is have this code choose which other constructor you call. But as all of them must route to the primary one, you do not lose much. Also, you need the other constructor you call to have at least one argument. If there are several constructors, the primary one should normally not be the one without an argument (see Scala problem optional constructor)