Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

C++/CLI optional arguments

Why i cannot declare default arguments for member functions of a managed type or generic functions? C# 4.0 introduced Named and Optional Arguments; there is a similar thing for CLI?

I do not understand why is not possible to declare a method like this:

void Optional(int argument = 0);

And then when I call Optional(); the compiler does not translate this call into: Optional(0);.

like image 832
gliderkite Avatar asked Apr 25 '12 12:04

gliderkite


People also ask

Does C support optional arguments?

C does not support optional parameters.

How do I find command line arguments?

First of all, to check if there is an argument, you should use the argc variable of the main(int argc, char** argv) , which indicates the length of your argv array.

What is Getopt in C?

The getopt() is one of the built-in C function that are used for taking the command line options. The syntax of this function is like below − getopt(int argc, char *const argv[], const char *optstring) The opstring is a list of characters. Each of them representing a single character option.

How do you make a method parameter optional?

By Params Keyword: You can implement optional parameters by using the params keyword. It allows you to pass any variable number of parameters to a method. But you can use the params keyword for only one parameter and that parameter is the last parameter of the method.


1 Answers

It looks like the C++/CLI Compiler doesn't emit the correct IL directive for that. It doesn't emit the directive .param [1] = int32(0), which C# uses for recognizing default parameters. If you open the generated assembly in ILDasm, you'll see it.

A way that compiles would be to use the attributes Optional and DefaultParameterValue from the System::Runtime::InteropServices namespace, but C# doesn't use those for default parameters, so currently there's no easy way around creating an overload.

You can find the question asking about those Attributes here: https://stackoverflow.com/a/4974528/93652

like image 59
Botz3000 Avatar answered Oct 14 '22 06:10

Botz3000