Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Blinding a latex paper

Many journals require submission of a blinded version of your paper. The blinded version usually removes:

  • the list of authors
  • any citations to the authors' work

How can I create a blinded version of my manuscript without doing this manually?

like image 216
hadley Avatar asked May 10 '09 15:05

hadley


2 Answers

You could use the extract package to generate a separate LaTeX source file for the paper with the author list and acknowledgements automatically removed. I believe the versions package could be used to do this as well.

As for blinding the citations, I think the point is to refer to your own work in a neutral and unrevealing way. Here are some examples of correct and incorrect ways to cite your own work in a blinded manuscript:

Incorrect: "As I have argued elsewhere..."
Corrected: "As Jones (2001) has argued..."

Incorrect: "As I argue in (Jones 2001)."
Corrected: "As Jones (2001) argues."

Incorrect: "This argument is fleshed out in my (2001)." 
Corrected: "Jones (2001) makes this argument in more detail."
like image 162
las3rjock Avatar answered Oct 02 '22 17:10

las3rjock


One thing that is often overlooked in these cases, is that you do not really need to remove citations of your own work, as long as you refer to them in the third person. Instead of writing "As shown in our previous paper (Removed for review) ...", you should write "As shown by Smith et al. (Smith, Jones, and Adams, 2008)...".

This reads much better and saves you some of the trouble, while typically satisfying the submission rules for journals and conference. This way all you have to do is remove the list of authors, which is not hard to do by hand.

like image 43
Dima Avatar answered Oct 02 '22 18:10

Dima