At what point is it worth using a database?

Question

I have a question relating to databases and at what point is worth diving into one. I am primarily an embedded engineer, but I am writing an application using Qt to interface with our controller.

We are at an odd point where we have enough data that it would be feasible to implement a database (around 700+ items and growing) to manage everything, but I am not sure it is worth the time right now to deal with. I have no problems implementing the GUI with files generated from excel and parsed in, but it gets tedious and hard to track even with VBA scripts. I have been playing around with converting our data into something more manageable for the application side with Microsoft Access and that seems to be working well. If that works out I am only a step (or several) away from using an SQL database and using the Qt library to access and modify it.

I don't have much experience managing data at this level and am curious what may be the best way to approach this. So what are some of the real benefits of using a database if any in this case? I realize much of this can be very application specific, but some general ideas and suggestions on how to straddle the embedded/application programming line would be helpful.

This is not about putting a database in an embedded project. It is also not a business type application where larger databases are commonly used. I am designing a GUI for a single user on a desktop to interface with a micro-controller for monitoring and configuration purposes.

---

I decided to go with SQLite. You can do some very interesting things with data that I didn't really consider an option when first starting this project.

Answer 1

A database is worthwhile when:

1. Your application evolves to some form of data driven execution.
2. You're spending time designing and developing external data storage structures.
3. Sharing data between applications or organizations (including individual people)
4. The data is no longer short and simple.
5. Data Duplication

Evolution to Data Driven Execution
When the data is changing but the execution is not, this is a sign of a data driven program or parts of the program are data driven. A set of configuration options is a sign of a data driven function, but the whole application may not be data driven. In any case, a database can help manage the data. (The database library or application does not have to be huge like Oracle, but can be lean and mean like SQLite).

Design & Development of External Data Structures
Posting questions to Stack Overflow about serialization or converting trees and lists to use files is a good indication your program has graduated to using a database. Also, if you are spending any amount of time designing algorithms to store data in a file or designing the data in a file is a good time to research the usage of a database.

Sharing Data
Whether your application is sharing data with another application, another organization or another person, a database can assist. By using a database, data consistency is easier to achieve. One of the big issues in problem investigation is that teams are not using the same data. The customer may use one set of data; the validation team another and development using a different set of data. A database makes versioning the data easier and allows entities to use the same data.

Complex Data
Programs start out using small tables of hard coded data. This evolves into using dynamic data with maps, trees and lists. Sometimes the data expands from simple two columns to 8 or more. Database theory and databases can ease the complexity of organizing data. Let the database worry about managing the data and free up your application and your development time. After all, how the data is managed is not as important as to the quality of the data and it's accessibility.

Data Duplication
Often times, when data grows, there is an ever growing attraction for duplicate data. Databases and database theory can minimize the duplication of data. Databases can be configured to warn against duplications.

Moving to using a database has many factors to be considered. Some include but are not limited to: data complexity, data duplication (including parts of the data), project deadlines, development costs and licensing issues. If your program can run more efficiently with a database, then do so. A database may also save development time (and money). There are other tasks that you and your application can be performing than managing data. Leave data management up to the experts.