Are Traits good or bad?

Question

This is an open-ended question, but I would like to solicit some opinions from the SO community on Traits; do you think Traits in Squeak/Pharo are a good thing, or should you stay away from them and use composition and delegation instead? I ask because while I know how to use them (thanks to the Pharo book), I am not really sure how acceptable it is to use them or where it is OK to use them and where it isn't.

Answer 1

I do not like traits because they introduce strong dependencies into code. These dependencies can be obvious (a class that imports a trait, a trait that expects methods), but also very subtle (a trait that shadows super methods/instance variables). Furthermore there is no adequate tool support for traits.

In my experience delegation gives a much better and more reusable design in a dynamically typed object-oriented language like Smalltalk.