xkcd: Externalities

Question

So the April 1, 2013 xkcd Externalities web comic features a Skein 1024 1024 hash breaking contest. I'm assuming that this must be nothing more than a brute force effort where random strings are hashed in an effort to match Randall's posted hash? Is this correct?

Also, my knowledge of Skein hashing theory is virtually non-existent but being a halfway decent programmer I was able to download and run both SkeinFish (C#) and Maarten Bodewes Skein implementation (Java) locally in 1024 1024 mode with some input strings. The hashes that they gave, however, were different than the hash that xkcd returned for the same input. This may be an extremely naive question but do different Skein implementations give different hashes? And what Skein implementation is xkcd using?

Thanks for pardoning my ignorance!

Answer 1

There are several different iterations of the skein algorithm. XKCD is using version 1.3, which is also the most recent. Sources can be found here (look for "V1.3")

Interestingly enough, this brute-force method is the same one employed by Bitcoin to "mine" bitcoins. The big differences are the hash algorithm (SHA-256 in that case) and the target hash (which is dynamically determined to be any hash starting with a certain number of zeros.) It takes a lot of work to discover the hash, but once it has been found it is trivial to verify the source bits and that the resulting hash meets the criteria.