Why does a read-only open of a named pipe block?

Question

I've noticed a couple of oddities when dealing with named pipes (FIFOs) under various flavors of UNIX (Linux, FreeBSD and MacOS X) using Python. The first, and perhaps most annoying is that attempts to open an empty/idle FIFO read-only will block (unless I use os.O_NONBLOCK with the lower level os.open() call). However, if I open it for read/write then I get no blocking.

Examples:

f = open('./myfifo', 'r')               # Blocks unless data is already in the pipe f = os.open('./myfifo', os.O_RDONLY)    # ditto  # Contrast to: f = open('./myfifo', 'w+')                           # does NOT block f = os.open('./myfifo', os.O_RDWR)                   # ditto f = os.open('./myfifo', os.O_RDONLY|os.O_NONBLOCK)   # ditto 

I'm just curious why. Why does the open call block rather than some subsequent read operation?

Also I've noticed that a non-blocking file descriptor can exhibit to different behaviors in Python. In the case where I use os.open() with the os.O_NONBLOCK for the initial opening operation then an os.read() seems to return an empty string if data isn't ready on the file descriptor. However, if I use fcntl.fcnt(f.fileno(), fcntl.F_SETFL, fcntl.GETFL | os.O_NONBLOCK) then an os.read raises an exception (errno.EWOULDBLOCK)

Is there some other flag being set by the normal open() that's not set by my os.open() example? How are they different and why?

Answer 1

That's just the way it's defined. From the Open Group page for the open() function

O_NONBLOCK      When opening a FIFO with O_RDONLY or O_WRONLY set: If O_NONBLOCK is     set:          An open() for reading only will return without delay. An open()         for writing only will return an error if no process currently         has the file open for reading.      If O_NONBLOCK is clear:          An open() for reading only will block the calling thread until a         thread opens the file for writing. An open() for writing only         will block the calling thread until a thread opens the file for         reading.