What's the idiomatic way to do async socket programming in Delphi?

Question

What is the normal way people writing network code in Delphi use Windows-style overlapped asynchronous socket I/O?

Here's my prior research into this question:

The Indy components seem entirely synchronous. On the other hand, while ScktComp unit does use WSAAsyncSelect, it basically only asynchronizes a BSD-style multiplexed socket app. You get dumped in a single event callback, as if you had just returned from select() in a loop, and have to do all the state machine navigation yourself.

The .NET situation is considerably nicer, with Socket.BeginRead / Socket.EndRead, where the continuation is passed directly to Socket.BeginRead, and that's where you pick back up. A continuation coded as a closure obviously has all the context you need, and more.

Answer 1

I have found that Indy, while a simpler concept in the beginning, is awkward to manage due to the need to kill sockets to free threads at application termination. In addition, I had the Indy library stop working after an OS patch upgrade. ScktComp works well for my application.

Answer 2

@Roddy - Synchronous sockets are not what I'm after. Burning a whole thread for the sake of a possibly long-lived connection means you limit the amount of concurrent connections to the number of threads that your process can contain. Since threads use a lot of resources - reserved stack address space, committed stack memory, and kernel transitions for context switches - they do not scale when you need to support hundreds of connections, much less thousands or more.