What is the difference between launch/join and async/await in Kotlin coroutines

Question

• launch is used to fire and forget coroutine. It is like starting a new thread. If the code inside the launch terminates with exception, then it is treated like uncaught exception in a thread -- usually printed to stderr in backend JVM applications and crashes Android applications. join is used to wait for completion of the launched coroutine and it does not propagate its exception. However, a crashed child coroutine cancels its parent with the corresponding exception, too.

• async is used to start a coroutine that computes some result. The result is represented by an instance of Deferred and you must use await on it. An uncaught exception inside the async code is stored inside the resulting Deferred and is not delivered anywhere else, it will get silently dropped unless processed. You MUST NOT forget about the coroutine you’ve started with async.

I find this guide https://github.com/Kotlin/kotlinx.coroutines/blob/master/coroutines-guide.md to be useful. I will quote the essential parts

🦄 coroutine

Essentially, coroutines are light-weight threads.

So you can think of coroutine as something that manages thread in a very efficient way.

🐤 launch

fun main(args: Array<String>) {
    launch { // launch new coroutine in background and continue
        delay(1000L) // non-blocking delay for 1 second (default time unit is ms)
        println("World!") // print after delay
    }
    println("Hello,") // main thread continues while coroutine is delayed
    Thread.sleep(2000L) // block main thread for 2 seconds to keep JVM alive
}

So launch starts a background thread, does something, and returns a token immediately as Job. You can call join on this Job to block until this launch thread completes

fun main(args: Array<String>) = runBlocking<Unit> {
    val job = launch { // launch new coroutine and keep a reference to its Job
        delay(1000L)
        println("World!")
    }
    println("Hello,")
    job.join() // wait until child coroutine completes
}

🦆 async

Conceptually, async is just like launch. It starts a separate coroutine which is a light-weight thread that works concurrently with all the other coroutines. The difference is that launch returns a Job and does not carry any resulting value, while async returns a Deferred -- a light-weight non-blocking future that represents a promise to provide a result later.

So async starts a background thread, does something, and returns a token immediately as Deferred.

fun main(args: Array<String>) = runBlocking<Unit> {
    val time = measureTimeMillis {
        val one = async { doSomethingUsefulOne() }
        val two = async { doSomethingUsefulTwo() }
        println("The answer is ${one.await() + two.await()}")
    }
    println("Completed in $time ms")
}

You can use .await() on a deferred value to get its eventual result, but Deferred is also a Job, so you can cancel it if needed.

So Deferred is actually a Job. See https://kotlin.github.io/kotlinx.coroutines/kotlinx-coroutines-core/kotlinx.coroutines.experimental/-deferred/index.html

interface Deferred<out T> : Job (source)

🦋 async is eager by default

There is a laziness option to async using an optional start parameter with a value of CoroutineStart.LAZY. It starts coroutine only when its result is needed by some await or if a start function is invoked.

launch and async are used to start new coroutines. But, they execute them in different manner.

I would like to show very basic example which will help you understand difference very easily

1. launch

    class MainActivity : AppCompatActivity() {

    override fun onCreate(savedInstanceState: Bundle?) {
        super.onCreate(savedInstanceState)
        setContentView(R.layout.activity_main)

        btnCount.setOnClickListener {
            pgBar.visibility = View.VISIBLE
            CoroutineScope(Dispatchers.Main).launch {
                val currentMillis = System.currentTimeMillis()
                val retVal1 = downloadTask1()
                val retVal2 = downloadTask2()
                val retVal3 = downloadTask3()
                Toast.makeText(applicationContext, "All tasks downloaded! ${retVal1}, ${retVal2}, ${retVal3} in ${(System.currentTimeMillis() - currentMillis)/1000} seconds", Toast.LENGTH_LONG).show();
                pgBar.visibility = View.GONE
            }
        }

    // Task 1 will take 5 seconds to complete download
    private suspend fun downloadTask1() : String {
        kotlinx.coroutines.delay(5000);
        return "Complete";
    }

    // Task 1 will take 8 seconds to complete download    
    private suspend fun downloadTask2() : Int {
        kotlinx.coroutines.delay(8000);
        return 100;
    }

    // Task 1 will take 5 seconds to complete download
    private suspend fun downloadTask3() : Float {
        kotlinx.coroutines.delay(5000);
        return 4.0f;
    }
}

In this example, my code is downloading 3 data on click of btnCount button and showing pgBar progress bar until all download gets completed. There are 3 suspend functions downloadTask1(), downloadTask2() and downloadTask3() which downloads data. To simulate it, I've used delay() in these functions. These functions waits for 5 seconds, 8 seconds and 5 seconds respectively.

As we've used launch for starting these suspend functions, launch will execute them sequentially (one-by-one). This means that, downloadTask2() would start after downloadTask1() gets completed and downloadTask3() would start only after downloadTask2() gets completed.

As in output screenshot Toast, total execution time to complete all 3 downloads would lead to 5 seconds + 8 seconds + 5 seconds = 18 seconds with launch

2. async

As we saw that launch makes execution sequentially for all 3 tasks. The time to complete all tasks was 18 seconds.

If those tasks are independent and if they do not need other task's computation result, we can make them run concurrently. They would start at same time and run concurrently in background. This can be done with async.

async returns an instance of Deffered<T> type, where T is type of data our suspend function returns. For example,

• downloadTask1() would return Deferred<String> as String is return type of function
• downloadTask2() would return Deferred<Int> as Int is return type of function
• downloadTask3() would return Deferred<Float> as Float is return type of function

We can use the return object from async of type Deferred<T> to get the returned value in T type. That can be done with await() call. Check below code for example

        btnCount.setOnClickListener {
        pgBar.visibility = View.VISIBLE

        CoroutineScope(Dispatchers.Main).launch {
            val currentMillis = System.currentTimeMillis()
            val retVal1 = async(Dispatchers.IO) { downloadTask1() }
            val retVal2 = async(Dispatchers.IO) { downloadTask2() }
            val retVal3 = async(Dispatchers.IO) { downloadTask3() }

            Toast.makeText(applicationContext, "All tasks downloaded! ${retVal1.await()}, ${retVal2.await()}, ${retVal3.await()} in ${(System.currentTimeMillis() - currentMillis)/1000} seconds", Toast.LENGTH_LONG).show();
            pgBar.visibility = View.GONE
        }

This way, we've launched all 3 tasks concurrently. So, my total execution time to complete would be only 8 seconds which is time for downloadTask2() as it is largest of all of 3 tasks. You can see this in following screenshot in Toast message

1. both coroutine builders namely launch and async are basically lambdas with receiver of type CoroutineScope which means their inner block is compiled as a suspend function, hence they both run in an asynchronous mode AND they both will execute their block sequentially.

2. The difference between launch and async is that they enable two different possibilities. The launch builder returns a Job however the async function will return a Deferred object. You can use launch to execute a block that you don't expect any returned value from it i.e writing to a database or saving a file or processing something basically just called for its side effect. On the other hand async which return a Deferred as I stated previously returns a useful value from the execution of its block, an object that wraps your data, so you can use it for mainly its result but possibly for its side effect as well. N.B: you can strip the deferred and get its value using the function await, which will block the execution of your statements until a value is returned or an exceptions is thrown! You could achieve the same thing with launch by using the function join()

3. both coroutine builder (launch and async) are cancelable.

4. anything more?: yep with launch if an exception is thrown within its block, the coroutine is automatically canceled and the exceptions is delivered. On the other hand, if that happens with async the exception is not propagated further and should be caught/handled within the returned Deferred object.

5. more on coroutines https://kotlinlang.org/docs/tutorials/coroutines/coroutines-basic-jvm.html https://www.codementor.io/blog/kotlin-coroutines-6n53p8cbn1