Menu
I am interested in Behavior Driven Development (BDD)
Are there any good frameworks and/or tooling available for the .Net platform (preferably C# and ASP.Net)?
And when has BDD proved most appropriate to use in real world scenarios? (auxiliary question)
861
Lettuce. Lettuce is a very simple BDD tool based on Cucumber. It can execute plain-text functional descriptions as automated tests for Python projects. Lettuce aims the most common tasks on BDD.
Cucumber-JVM and JBehave are the two most popular BDD frameworks for Java and popular JVM languages (e.g., Scala and Closure). JBehave is one of the original BDD frameworks developed by BDD Godfather Dan North, but it lacks some common Gherkin features, whereas Cucumber-JVM is fully Gherkin-compliant solution.
The BDD process moves through three phases—discovery, formulation, and automation—where the acceptance criteria are transformed into acceptance tests that are later automated.
+1 for people's recommendation of SpecFlow for scenarios; never used it but heard many good things about it. I've been using plain old NUnit with a little DSL like this. MSTest would work similarly.
You can also do BDD in the unit space, which is what MSpec is designed to do. I'm personally hating MSpec, but the rest of the team here love it. They like writing examples of how the code works. I like to show why the behavior is valuable. It's a subtle distinction and if you're not worried about doing this at a unit level it won't hit you.
Other frameworks to look at include Concordion, Fitnesse.NET (please put FitSharp behind it!) and TickSpec.
In the real world, the most valuable bit of BDD by a long way is the conversations, not the automated tests. Here's a couple of quick hints and tips for making it work:
Don't write automated tests over things which are in flux. It just commits you to stuff you got wrong. Wait until the UI has settled a bit then do it.
If you don't care much about your UI, but do care about data integrity, write the scenarios over the controller / presenter layer (eg: for admin screens).
Don't start with login. Start by describing a valuable part of the application for which you might log in. Do that first (assume you only have one user). You'll get quicker feedback on the risky bits.
Seek quick feedback on the risky bits, which will usually be the bits which you've never done before. Use scenarios to have conversations around them. Write anything interesting you discover down, but forget the scenarios which are obvious - they're obvious! Don't worry about automating them to start with. Having conversations is more important than writing down conversations is more important than automating conversations.
Good luck! If you want to know more about BDD, I put together a page of relevant links here.
71
On googling I found Behavior Driven Development (BDD) with SpecFlow and ASP.NET MVC. You might find it useful, take a look. Also go through Behavior-Driven Development with SpecFlow and WatiN
A nice presentation on Pros and Cons of BDD
A channel 9 video Behavior-Driven Development in the Real World
and last but not least an InfoQ article Behavior Driven Development In .NET
20
If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!
Donate Us With
