We need to pickle any sort of callable

Question

Recently a question was posed regarding some Python code attempting to facilitate distributed computing through the use of pickled processes. Apparently, that functionality has historically been possible, but for security reasons the same functionality is disabled. On the second attempted at transmitting a function object through a socket, only the reference was transmitted. Correct me if I am wrong, but I do not believe this issue is related to Python's late binding. Given the presumption that process and thread objects can not be pickled, is there any way to transmit a callable object? We would like to avoid transmitting compressed source code for each job, as that would probably make the entire attempt pointless. Only the Python core library can be used for portability reasons.

Answer 1

You could marshal the bytecode and pickle the other function things:

import marshal
import pickle

marshaled_bytecode = marshal.dumps(your_function.func_code)
# In this process, other function things are lost, so they have to be sent separated.
pickled_name = pickle.dumps(your_function.func_name)
pickled_arguments = pickle.dumps(your_function.func_defaults)
pickled_closure = pickle.dumps(your_function.func_closure)
# Send the marshaled bytecode and the other function things through a socket (they are byte strings).
send_through_a_socket((marshaled_bytecode, pickled_name, pickled_arguments, pickled_closure))

In another python program:

import marshal
import pickle
import types

# Receive the marshaled bytecode and the other function things.
marshaled_bytecode, pickled_name, pickled_arguments, pickled_closure = receive_from_a_socket()
your_function = types.FunctionType(marshal.loads(marshaled_bytecode), globals(), pickle.loads(pickled_name), pickle.loads(pickled_arguments), pickle.loads(pickled_closure))

And any references to globals inside the function would have to be recreated in the script that receives the function.

In Python 3, the function attributes used are __code__, __name__, __defaults__ and __closure__.

Please do note that send_through_a_socket and receive_from_a_socket do not actually exist, and you should replace them by actual code that transmits data through sockets.