Trying out Test-Driven Development

Question

After reading this post I kinda felt in the same position as the guy who asked the question. I love technology and coming up with new ideas to solve real world problems just gets my neurons horny, but the other part of the equation - actually getting things done (fast) - is normally a pain in the ass to accomplish, specially when I'm doing this for myself.

Sometimes I kinda feel plain bored with code, some other times I spend more time moving the cursor in the text editor and staring at my code, trying to come up with a solution that is better than the one I already have. I heard this is a disease called perfectionism.

I've read in that same post (and also a few times here on SO too) that TDD is actually good to stop coding like a girl, however I've never given a chance at TDD - either because I'm too lazy to learn / set it up or because I don't think I need it because I can do all the tests I need inside my head.

• Do you also believe that TDD actually helps to GTD?
• What do I need to know about TDD?
• What about alternatives to TDD?
• What would be the best methodology to organize / develop a TDD web app?
• What libraries should I use (if any) to make my life easier?

PS: I'm primarily (but not exclusively) working with PHP here.

Answer 1

Personally I think TDD is at best overkill and at worst an impediment to a the creative process of programming. Time that is spent laboriously writing unit tests for each as yet unwritten methods/classes would be better spent solving the original problem. That being said I am a big fan of unit tests and believe wholeheartedly in them. If I have a particularly complex or troublesome piece of code I'm more than happy to write 20 unit tests for a single method but generally AFTER I have solved the problem. TDD, just like every other programming paradigm, is no silver bullet. If is suits you use it if not keep looking.

But take my opinion with a grain of salt. A much more interesting one comes from Kent Beck and How deep are your unit tests?.