Test::More doesn't know if test dies - so how do I test?

Question

I'm collecting a bunch of subroutines that are common to a bunch of my scripts into a module. (I should've done this way earlier, but started out with inherited scripts.) I'm modelling my work on the very helpful example here, using Test::More and Module::Build

All of the subroutines that read or write from files all include a line open() or die "errmsg". I'm in the process of writing a test for the module and ran across this problem. One of the subroutines checks whether a path points to something or not, dying on fail. In the inherited scripts, the subroutine looks like this:

sub checkExist {
  my ($type, $path) = @_;
  if ($type eq 'd') {
    if (! -d $path) {
      warn("dir not found: $path\n");
      die $pathNotFound;
    }
  }
  elsif ($type eq 'f') {
    if (! -f $path) {
      warn("file not found: $path\n");
      die $pathNotFound;
    }
    elsif (! -s $path) {
      warn("empty file: $path\n");
      die $emptyFile;
    }
  }
}

now, I'm testing this with the following line:

is(HomeBrew::IO::checkExist('f', $0), '', "can checkExist find file $0 ?");

which works fine unless I pick a path which doesn't doesn't exist, in which case the test script dies, but the test succeeds, producing the following output:

# Looks like your test exited with 2 just after 5.
Dubious, test returned 2 (wstat 512, 0x200)
All 5 subtests passed 

I would prefer if this were a failing test (rather than a dubious pass), but since this is legacy code, I also want this subroutine to halt execution on fail. What to do? Is it stupid to write a test on a function this simple?

I've already written a checkExist2 function that I'll be using in the future that returns undef on success else a non-zero error (so I can write die if checkExist2() elsewhere). Other suggestions that do not maintain the functionality of checkExist are welcome.

Answer 1

The proper way to test if code lives, or dies with a proper error, is with Test::Exception. You can wrap this test around other test cases, since it just takes a coderef:

use Test::More;
use Test::Exception;

lives_ok {
    is(HomeBrew::IO::checkExist('f', $0), '',
    "can checkExist find file $0 ?")
} '...and code does not die';

Answer 2

Why not have a helper subroutine in your test module which wraps an eval{} around HomeBrew::IO::checkExist call and checks for a fail via $@?

sub runcheckExist {
   my $res = eval { HomeBrew::IO::checkExist('f', $0) };
   # May want more logic here 
   # for checking $@ for specific error text pattern
   # or $res
   return $@ ? 1 : 0;
}
my $expect_to_die = 1;
is(runcheckExist(), $expect_to_die, "can checkExist find file $0 ?");