Spring @Transactional method - participating transaction

Question

in one dao I have 2 @Transactional methods.

if i do not provide any explicit properties,

then what will happen, if

I run one method in the body of another?

Both methods will run within THE SAME ONE TRANSACTION?

Answer 1

Proxies in Spring AOP

When using Transactional, you're dealing with proxies of classes, so in this scenario:

@Transactional
public void doSomeThing(){ // calling this method targets a proxy

    doSomeThingElse(); // this method targets the actual class, not the PROXY,
                       // so the transactional annotation has no effect
}

@Transactional
public void doSomeThingElse(){
}

you are calling the proxy from outside, but the second method call is made from inside the proxied object and therefor has no transactional support. So naturally, they run in the same transaction, no matter what the values of the @Transactional annotation in the second method are

so if you need separate transactions, you have to call

yourservice.doSomething();
yourservice.doSomethingElse();

from outside.

The whole scenario is explained pretty well in the chapter Spring AOP > Understanding AOP proxies, including this "solution":

Accessing the Current AOP Proxy object from the inside

public class SimplePojo implements Pojo {

   public void foo() {
      // this works, but... gah!
      ((Pojo) AopContext.currentProxy()).bar();
   }

   public void bar() {
      // some logic...
   }
}