Specific A* Pathfinding Issue with Implementation

Question

I'm having some issues with my A* Implementation. It occasionally decides to do strange things on my grid, like ignoring movement costs and moving thru a high cost area, or going a tile in the wrong direction before getting back on track.

I've officially spent far too many hours on it then I'd like to admit so I'm reaching out to find a pair of fresh eyes.

private List<Vector2> PathFromTo(Vector2 startID, Vector2 targetID){
    List<Vector2> path = new List<Vector2> ();
    List<Node> closedList = new List<Node> ();
    List<Node> openList = new List<Node> ();
    Node startNode = nodeList.Find (tgt => tgt.nodeID == new Vector2 (startID.x, startID.y));
    if (startNode == null)
        return path;
    Node targetNode = nodeList.Find (tgt => tgt.nodeID == new Vector2 (targetID.x, targetID.y));
    if (targetNode == null)
        return path;

    openList.Add (startNode);

    while (openList.Count > 0) {
        Node current = openList [0];
        for (int i = 1; i < openList.Count; i++) 
            if (openList [i].GetFCost () <= current.GetFCost () && openList [i].GetHCost () < current.GetHCost ()) 
                current = openList [i];

        openList.Remove (current);
        closedList.Add (current);

        if (current == targetNode) {
            RetracePath (startNode, targetNode, ref path);
            return path;
        }

        foreach(Vector2 neighbour in current.neighbors) {
            Node neighbourNode = nodeList.Find (tgt => tgt.nodeID == new Vector2 (neighbour.x, neighbour.y));
            CheckNeighbor(ref neighbourNode, ref current, ref targetNode, ref closedList, ref openList);
        }
    }
    return path;
}

private void CheckNeighbor(ref Node neighborTile, ref Node currentTile, ref Node targetTile, ref List<Node> closedList, ref List<Node> openList){
    if (neighborTile != null) {
        if (!neighborTile.passable || closedList.Contains (neighborTile)) {
        } else {
            int newCostToNeighbor = (int)(currentTile.moveCost + CalculateDistance (currentTile.position, neighborTile.position));
            if (newCostToNeighbor < neighborTile.GetGCost() || !openList.Contains (neighborTile)) {
                neighborTile.SetGCost (newCostToNeighbor);
                neighborTile.SetHCost (CalculateDistance (neighborTile.position, targetTile.position));
                neighborTile.SetParent (currentTile);

                if (!openList.Contains (neighborTile)) 
                    openList.Add (neighborTile);
            }
        }
    }
}

public float CalculateDistance(Vector2 tileA_pos, Vector2 tileB_pos){ 
    float dX = Mathf.Abs (tileB_pos.x - tileA_pos.x); 
    float dY = Mathf.Abs (tileB_pos.y - tileA_pos.y); 
    float shift1 = -(tileA_pos.x + tileA_pos.y); 
    float shift2 = -(tileB_pos.x + tileB_pos.y); 
    float dZ = Mathf.Abs (shift2 - shift1); 
    return Mathf.Max (dX, dY, dZ); 
}

private void RetracePath(Node start, Node end, ref List<Vector2> pathInfo){
    pathInfo = new List<Vector2> ();
    Node current = end;
    while (current != start) {
        pathInfo.Add (current.nodeID);
        current = current.GetParent ();
    }
    pathInfo.Reverse ();
}

Answer 1

Given the CalculateDistance method you show in the comments I wrote the following test program: (Assuming your Mathf is similar to System.Math)

for (int y = -4; y < 5; y++)
{
    for (int x = -4; x < 5; x++)
    {
        var dst = CalculateDistance(new Vector2(x, y), new Vector2());
        Console.Write($"{((int)dst):D1} ");
    }
    Console.WriteLine();
}

The test program tests all coordinates between (-4,-4) and (4, 4) and calculates their distance to (0,0) The output:

8 7 6 5 4 4 4 4 4
7 6 5 4 3 3 3 3 4
6 5 4 3 2 2 2 3 4
5 4 3 2 1 1 2 3 4
4 3 2 1 0 1 2 3 4
4 3 2 1 1 2 3 4 5
4 3 2 2 2 3 4 5 6
4 3 3 3 3 4 5 6 7
4 4 4 4 4 5 6 7 8

As you can see the output is completely wacky, you would expect the bottom right corner to be just as far from (0,0) as the top right corner, but it isn't. Perhaps you need to rewrite your CalculateDistance method.

You seem to calculate a dX, dY and dZ, which is impossible given you have only 2 coordinates (Vector2).

---

Edit: You can simpy use pythagoras to figure out the distance between two points if no 'weights' are recorded:

var dist = Math.Sqrt(Math.Pow(point1.x - point2.x, 2) + Math.Pow(point1.y - point2.y, 2));