Servlet vs RESTful

Question

Today I read about Restful services. Basically what I understand that is Restful webservices will work on HTTP request methods rather than normal webservice will work on SOAP request.

What is the need for Restful services as normal servlet can also work on the HTTP methods?

Answer 1

RESTful is more an architecture style than a different technology. In server perspective, it is designed to be entirely stateless and self-contained on a per-request basis (i.e. there are no sessions). In client perspective, it's more a way of getting information in different formats via URLs with (self-documenting) path parameters instead of request parameters.

Surely you can do this with a plain vanilla servlet, but it would introduce some boilerplate code to gather the path parameters and to generate the desired response. JAX-RS is just a convenient and self-containing API which removes the need for writing all the boilerplate code yourself, resulting in minimal and more self-documenting code.

Assuming that you've a JAXB entity as model as below:

@XmlRootElement public class Data {      @XmlElement     private Long id;      @XmlElement     private String value;      // ...      @Override     public String toString() {         return String.format("Data[id=%d,value=%s]", id, value);     }  } 

And a JAX-RS resource as below:

@Path("data") public class DataResource {      @EJB     private DataService service;      @GET      @Path("text/{id}")     @Produces(MediaType.TEXT_PLAIN)     public String getAsText(@PathParam("id") Long id) {         return String.valueOf(service.find(id));     }      @GET      @Path("xml/{id}")     @Produces(MediaType.APPLICATION_XML)     public Data getAsXml(@PathParam("id") Long id) {         return service.find(id);     }      @GET      @Path("json/{id}")     @Produces(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)     public Data getAsJson(@PathParam("id") Long id) {         return service.find(id);     }  } 

Then you'd already get the desired content in proper format by:

• http://example.com/rest/data/text/123
• http://example.com/rest/data/xml/123
• http://example.com/rest/data/json/123

That's it. Try to do the same with a single plain vanilla Servlet :) Please note that SOAP essentially also goes over HTTP. It's basically an extra XML layer over HTTP, not a different network protocol.

See also:

• REST tutorial
• JAXB tutorial
• Jersey tutorial