Python try-else

Question

What is the intended use of the optional else clause of the try statement?

Answer 1

The statements in the else block are executed if execution falls off the bottom of the try - if there was no exception. Honestly, I've never found a need.

However, Handling Exceptions notes:

The use of the else clause is better than adding additional code to the try clause because it avoids accidentally catching an exception that wasn’t raised by the code being protected by the try ... except statement.

So, if you have a method that could, for example, throw an IOError, and you want to catch exceptions it raises, but there's something else you want to do if the first operation succeeds, and you don't want to catch an IOError from that operation, you might write something like this:

try:     operation_that_can_throw_ioerror() except IOError:     handle_the_exception_somehow() else:     # we don't want to catch the IOError if it's raised     another_operation_that_can_throw_ioerror() finally:     something_we_always_need_to_do() 

If you just put another_operation_that_can_throw_ioerror() after operation_that_can_throw_ioerror, the except would catch the second call's errors. And if you put it after the whole try block, it'll always be run, and not until after the finally. The else lets you make sure

1. the second operation's only run if there's no exception,
2. it's run before the finally block, and
3. any IOErrors it raises aren't caught here

Answer 2

There is one big reason to use else - style and readability. It's generally a good idea to keep code that can cause exceptions near the code that deals with them. For example, compare these:

try:     from EasyDialogs import AskPassword     # 20 other lines     getpass = AskPassword except ImportError:     getpass = default_getpass 

and

try:     from EasyDialogs import AskPassword except ImportError:     getpass = default_getpass else:     # 20 other lines     getpass = AskPassword 

The second one is good when the except can't return early, or re-throw the exception. If possible, I would have written:

try:     from EasyDialogs import AskPassword except ImportError:     getpass = default_getpass     return False  # or throw Exception('something more descriptive')  # 20 other lines getpass = AskPassword 

Note: Answer copied from recently-posted duplicate here, hence all this "AskPassword" stuff.