Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

PostgreSQL sorting with Cyrillic "ь"

Just take a look, please:

WITH toks AS (
  SELECT tok
    FROM
      unnest('{ь, а, чь, ча, чль, чла}'::text[]) AS tok
  ORDER BY tok COLLATE "uk_UA"
)
SELECT ROW_NUMBER() OVER() AS "#", tok FROM toks
ORDER BY tok COLLATE "uk_UA"

PostgreSQL 9.3 (ubuntu) gives me this result:

 # | tok 
---+-----
 1 | а
 2 | ча
 3 | чль
 4 | чла
 5 | чь
 6 | ь
(6 rows)

Here rows 1, 2, 5 and 6 are sorted properly ("ь" goes after "а") while rows 3 and 4 are sorted wrongly ("а" goes after "ь").

All letters are Cyrillic, I've checked so many times.

Please, what's wrong and how to workaround .(

UPDATE: this is a bug which was fixed in mainstream recently: https://sourceware.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=17293

UPDATE2: Please note my own answer below.

like image 354
brownian Avatar asked Jun 30 '15 10:06

brownian


2 Answers

PostgreSQL relies on the operating system's locale to sort.

See how Ubuntu 14.04 sorts that list:

# locale-gen uk_UA.UTF-8
Generating locales...
  uk_UA.UTF-8... done
Generation complete.

# cat >file
ь
а
чь
ча
чль
чла

# LC_ALL=uk_UA.UTF-8 sort file
а
ча
чль
чла
чь
ь

In the comments you say it's different but what I get here is exactly the same order as your query.

Indeed чль comes before чла which intuitively is weird but I don't know cyrillic.

You may look at /usr/share/i18n/locales/uk_UA for the definition of the locale, and bring it up as an ubuntu bug of the locales packages.

like image 52
Daniel Vérité Avatar answered Nov 15 '22 15:11

Daniel Vérité


So, the solutions has been completed in these steps:

  1. Searched the Internet and http://linux.org.ua/ for any information; found http://linux.org.ua/cgi-bin/yabb/YaBB.pl?num=1407783417/6#6
  2. Starred at bug report: https://sourceware.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=17293, fixed 2015-05-26
  3. Checked glibc version (2.19 now)
  4. Grabbed a patch; edited the patch (removed the section for Makefile)
  5. Backed /usr/share/i18n/locales/uk_UA up
  6. Patched it with [cd /usr/share/i18n/;] patch --dry-run -p2 < locales_uk_UA_softsign.diff --- then with no --dry-run.
  7. locale-gen
  8. service postgresql restart
like image 3
brownian Avatar answered Nov 15 '22 15:11

brownian