PostgreSQL equivalent for MySQL GROUP BY

Question

I need to find duplicates in a table. In MySQL I simply write:

SELECT *,count(id) count FROM `MY_TABLE`
GROUP BY SOME_COLUMN ORDER BY count DESC

This query nicely:

• Finds duplicates based on SOME_COLUMN, giving its repetition count.
• Sorts in desc order of repetition, which is useful to quickly scan major dups.
• Chooses a random value for all remaining columns, giving me an idea of values in those columns.

Similar query in Postgres greets me with an error:

column "MY_TABLE.SOME_COLUMN" must appear in the GROUP BY clause or be used in an aggregate function

What is the Postgres equivalent of this query?

PS: I know that MySQL behaviour deviates from SQL standards.

Answer 1

Back-ticks are a non-standard MySQL thing. Use the canonical double quotes to quote identifiers (possible in MySQL, too). That is, if your table in fact is named "MY_TABLE" (all upper case). If you (more wisely) named it my_table (all lower case), then you can remove the double quotes or use lower case.

Also, I use ct instead of count as alias, because it is bad practice to use function names as identifiers.

Simple case

This would work with PostgreSQL 9.1:

SELECT *, count(id) ct
FROM   my_table
GROUP  BY primary_key_column(s)
ORDER  BY ct DESC;

It requires primary key column(s) in the GROUP BY clause. The results are identical to a MySQL query, but ct would always be 1 (or 0 if id IS NULL) - useless to find duplicates.

Group by other than primary key columns

If you want to group by other column(s), things get more complicated. This query mimics the behavior of your MySQL query - and you can use *.

SELECT DISTINCT ON (1, some_column)
       count(*) OVER (PARTITION BY some_column) AS ct
      ,*
FROM   my_table
ORDER  BY 1 DESC, some_column, id, col1;

This works because DISTINCT ON (PostgreSQL specific), like DISTINCT (SQL-Standard), are applied after the window function count(*) OVER (...). Window functions (with the OVER clause) require PostgreSQL 8.4 or later and are not available in MySQL.

Works with any table, regardless of primary or unique constraints.

The 1 in DISTINCT ON and ORDER BY is just shorthand to refer to the ordinal number of the item in the SELECT list.

SQL Fiddle to demonstrate both side by side.

More details in this closely related answer:

• Select first row in each GROUP BY group?

---

count(*) vs. count(id)

If you are looking for duplicates, you are better off with count(*) than with count(id). There is a subtle difference if id can be NULL, because NULL values are not counted - while count(*) counts all rows. If id is defined NOT NULL, results are the same, but count(*) is generally more appropriate (and slightly faster, too).

Answer 2

Here's another approach, uses DISTINCT ON:

select 

  distinct on(ct, some_column) 

  *,
  count(id) over(PARTITION BY some_column) as ct

from my_table x
order by ct desc, some_column, id

Data source:

CREATE TABLE my_table (some_column int, id int, col1 int);

INSERT INTO my_table  VALUES
 (1, 3,  4)
,(2, 4,  1)
,(2, 5,  1)
,(3, 6,  4)
,(3, 7,  3)
,(4, 8,  3)
,(4, 9,  4)
,(5, 10, 1)
,(5, 11, 2)
,(5, 11, 3);

Output:

SOME_COLUMN ID          COL1        CT
5           10          1           3
2           4           1           2
3           6           4           2
4           8           3           2
1           3           4           1

Live test: http://www.sqlfiddle.com/#!1/e2509/1

DISTINCT ON documentation: http://www.postgresonline.com/journal/archives/4-Using-Distinct-ON-to-return-newest-order-for-each-customer.html

Answer 3

mysql allows group by to omit non-aggregated selected columns from the group by list, which it executes by returning the first row found for each unique combination of grouped by columns. This is non-standard SQL behaviour.

postgres on the other hand is SQL standard compliant.

There is no equivalent query in postgres.