The problem - Generic description
As can be seen in help for about_pipelines (help pipeline
) powershell sends objects one at the time down the pipeline¹. So Get-Process -Name notepad | Stop-Process
sends one process at the time down the pipe.
Lets say we have a 3rd party CmdLet (Do-SomeStuff) that can't be modified or changed in any way. Do-SomeStuff perform different if it is passed an array of strings or if it is passed a single string object.
Do-SomeStuff is just an example, it could be substituted for ForEach-Object
, Select-Object
, Write-Host
(or any other CmdLet accepting pipeline input)
Do-SomeStuff will in this example process the individual items in the array one at the time.
$theArray = @("A", "B", "C") $theArray | Do-SomeStuff
If we want to send the complete array as one object to Do-SomeStuff one might try something like this
@($theArray) | Do-SomeStuff
But it does not produce the expected result since PowerShell "ignores" the new single-item-array.
So, how do you "force" $theArray
to be passed down the pipe as a single array-object instead of the content items one at the time?
The problem - practical example
As shown below the output of Write-Host
is different if passed an array or if it passed the individual items in the array one at the time.
PS C:\> $theArray = @("A", "B", "C") PS C:\> Write-Host $theArray A B C PS C:\> $theArray | foreach{Write-Host $_} A B C PS C:\> @($theArray) | foreach{Write-Host $_} A B C
How do you do to get $theArray | foreach{Write-Host $_}
to produce the same output as Write-Host $theArray
?
FOOTNOTES
A normal array of strings
PS C:\> @("A", "B", "C").GetType().FullName System.Object[]
A normal array of strings piped to Foreach-Object
PS C:\> @("A", "B", "C") | foreach{$_.GetType().FullName} System.String System.String System.String
Each string in the array is processed one at the time by the ForEach-Object CmdLet.
An array of arrays, where the "inner" arrays are arrays of strings.
PS C:\> @(@("A", "B", "C"), @("D", "E", "F"), @("G", "H", "I")) | foreach{$_.GetType().FullName} System.Object[] System.Object[] System.Object[]
Each array in the array is processed one at the time by the ForEach-Object CmdLet, and the content of each sub-array from the input is handled as one object even though it is an array.
Short answer: use unary array operator ,
:
,$theArray | foreach{Write-Host $_}
Long answer: there is one thing you should understand about @()
operator: it always interpret its content as statement, even if content is just an expression. Consider this code:
$a='A','B','C' $b=@($a;) $c=@($b;)
I add explicit end of statement mark ;
here, although PowerShell allows to omit it. $a
is array of three elements. What result of $a;
statement? $a
is a collection, so collection should be enumerated and each individual item should be passed by pipeline. So result of $a;
statement is three elements written to pipeline. @($a;)
see that three elements, but not the original array, and create array from them, so $b
is array of three elements. Same way $c
is array of same three elements. So when you write @($collection)
you create array, that copy elements of $collection
, instead of array of single element.
If you love us? You can donate to us via Paypal or buy me a coffee so we can maintain and grow! Thank you!
Donate Us With