Parsing Lines in Python: Use RE or Not?

Question

I'm a Perl programmer who's attempting to learn Python by taking some work I've done before and converting it over to Python. This is NOT a line-by-line translation. I want to learn the Python Technique to do this type of task.

I'm parsing a Windows INI file. Sections names are in the format:

[<type> <description>]

The <type> is a single word field and is not case sensitive. The <description> could be multiple words.

After a section, there are a bunch of parameters and values. These are in the form of:

 <parameter> = <value>

Parameters have no blank spaces and can only contain underscores, letters, and numbers (case insensitive). Thus, the first = is the divider between a parameter and the value. There might be white space separating the parameter and value around the equals sign. There might be extra white space at the beginning or end of the line.

In Perl, I used regular expressions for parsing:

while (my $line = <CONTROL_FILE>) {
    chomp($line);
    next if ($line =~ /^\s*[#;']/);     #Comments start with "#", ";", or "'"
    next if ($line =~ /^\s*$/);         #Ignore blank lines

    if ($line =~ /^\s*\[\s*(\w+)\s+(.*)/) {    #Section
        say "This is a '$1' section called '$2'";
    }
    elsif ($line =~ /^\s*(\w+)\s*=\s*(.*)/) {   #Parameter
       say "Parameter is '$1' with a value of '$2'";
    }
    else {      #Not Comment, Section, or Parameter
        say "Invalid line";
    }

}

The problem is that I've been corrupted by Perl, so I think the easiest way to do something is to use a regular expression. Here's the code I have so far...

 for line in file_handle:
     line = line.strip

     # Comment lines and blank lines
     if line.find("#") == 1 \
             or line.find(";") == 1 \
             or line.whitespace:
         continue

    # Found a Section Heading
    if line.find("[") == 1:
        print "I want to use a regular expression here"
        print "to split the section up into two pieces"
    elif line.find("=") != -1:
        print "I want to use a regular expression here"
        print "to split the parameter into key and value"
    else
        print "Invalid Line"

There are several things that irritate me here:

• There are two places where a regular expression just seem to be calling out to be used. What is the Python way of doing this splitting?
• I make sure to strip white space on either side of the string, and rewrite the string. That way, I don't have to do the stripping multiple times. However, I'm rewriting the string which I understand is a very inefficient operation in Python. What is the Python way to handle this issue?
• In the end, my algorithm looks pretty much like my Perl algorithm, and that seems to say that I am letting my Perl thinking get in the way. How should my code be structured in Python?

I've been going through the various on line tutorials, and they've helped me with understanding the syntax, but not much in the way of handling the language itself -- especially someone who tends to think in another language.

My question:

• Should I use regular expressions? Or, is there another and better way to handle this?
• Is my coding logic correct? How should I be thinking about parsing this file?

Answer 1

While I don't think this is your intention, the file format appears quite similar to Python's built-in ConfigParser module. Sometimes the most "Pythonic" way is already provided for you. (:

In more direct answer to your question: regular expressions may be a good way to do this. Otherwise, you could try the more basic (and less robust)

(parameter, value) = line.split('=')

This would throw an error if the line contained no or more than one '=' character. You may want to test it first with '=' in line.

Also:

line.find("[") == 1

is probably better replaced by

line.startswith("[")

Hope that helpls a little (:

Answer 2

Python includes a ini parsing library. If you want to build a library to parse ini files, then you are looking at an actual parser. Regex won't cut it, use PLY or hook in a flex/bison C parser. Additional python parsing resources are available as well.

Lexers handle all of the text consumption and tree construction for you, since it's a mechanical task prone to programmer error. I.E. this section:

while (my $line = <CONTROL_FILE>) {
    chomp($line);
    next if ($line =~ /^\s*[#;']/);     #Comments start with "#", ";", or "'"
    next if ($line =~ /^\s*$/);         #Ignore blank lines

    if ($line =~ /^\s*\[\s*(\w+)\s+(.*)/) {    #Section
        say "This is a '$1' section called '$2'";
    }
    elsif ($line =~ /^\s*(\w+)\s*=\s*(.*)/) {   #Parameter
       say "Parameter is '$1' with a value of '$2'";
    }
    else {      #Not Comment, Section, or Parameter
        say "Invalid line";
    }

}

Is created by the lexer, you just need to define the correct Regex. The parser pulls the tokens from the lexer, and determines if they fit the allowable token patterns. That is:

[<type> <description>]
<parameter> = <value>

Define those tokens, and then how the are allowed to fit. Everything else just puts itself together. For those of you who think you can do a better job with a quick for loop and some regex, I suggest you read Lex & Yacc, 2nd Ed.

For an example parser I wrote with PLY, go here. It parses a "jetLetter" file, which is just a dialect of groff/troff.