mysql drop foreign key without table copy

Question

I have an InnoDB table claims which has about 240 million rows. The table has a foreign key constraint: CONSTRAINT FK78744BD7307102A9 FOREIGN KEY (ID) REFERENCES claim_details (ID). I want to delete the table claim_details as quickly as possible.

Based on some experimentation it seems that if I use SET foreign_key_checks = 0; drop claim_details and then re-enable foreign keys, mysql will continue to enforce the constraint even though the table no longer exists. So, I believe I must drop the constraint from the table.

I have tried to use ALTER TABLE claims DROP FOREIGN KEY FK78744BD7307102A9 to drop the constraint and the query has been in a state of "copy to tmp table" for over 24 hours (on a machine with no other load). I don't understand why dropping a constraint requires making a copy of the table. Is there any way to prevent this?

mysql version 5.1.48.

Answer 1

Starting with MySQL 5.6, MySQL supports dropping of foreign keys in-place/without copying. Oracle calls this Online DDL.

This table lists all Online DDL operations and their runtime behavior.

From my experience, dropping foreign keys and the corresponding constraints on a 600GB table is almost instantaneous. With 5.5 it would probably have taken days.

The only disadvantage that I am aware of is, that 5.6 does not allow you to reclaim table space. I.e. if you are using innodb_file_per_table, that file will not shrink when you drop indices. Only the unused data in the file will grow. You can easily check using SHOW TABLE STATUS, and the Data_free column.