Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Maintaining code compatibility between OpenCV 2 and OpenCV 3

My library currently uses OpenCV 2. Now, I am trying to compile the library to use OpenCV 3. It seems that some header files were moved and some constants were renamed. For example, CV_INTER_LINEAR is not defined in OpenCV 3.

As my library needs to be compiled and run on both OpenCV 2 and 3, Is there any simple way to overcome this incompatibility?
I can change my code, but then it doesn't work in OpenCV 2.

like image 916
mans Avatar asked Apr 20 '15 14:04

mans


2 Answers

I had the same problem a few months ago, and I have to contraddict Kiran: I got my relatively big project to build both with OpenCv 2 and 3. Being able to build with both 2 and 3 is very important in a project transition phase, especially because OpenCV 3 is not in stable version yet, and yet has amazing optimization features.

Isn't cv::INTER_LINEAR defined both in OpenCV 2 (header imgproc/imgproc.hpp) and 3? You'll have to replace some constant names, add a couple of inclusions, but that won't be too hard.

Regarding header inclusions, there's a way to find an including path compatible both for Opencv2 and 3.

From the link Kiran posted:

In OpenCV 3 we write

#include "opencv2/core.hpp"

instead of

#include "opencv2/core/core.hpp"

The old method should also work.


Update
In the new Release Candidate, it's reported they have improved compatibility between OpenCV 2.4 and 3.x

Improved compatibility with OpenCV 2.4:

  • 2.4.11 now includes "opencv2/core.hpp" and other such headers in addition to standard "opencv2/core/core.hpp".
  • smart pointers (Ptr<>) can now be created in both 2.4 and 3.0 style (new ClassName(params) vs makePtr(params))
  • trained and stored stat models from opencv_ml 2.4 can now be loaded and used by opencv_ml 3.0 as-is.
  • the 2.4=>3.0 transition guide has been sketched: http://docs.opencv.org/master/db/dfa/tutorial_transition_guide.html
like image 168
Antonio Avatar answered Oct 28 '22 18:10

Antonio


EDIT:- Read Antonio's answer. You can include compatibility header types_c.h(1) and use OpenCV 2 constant names which works in OpenCV 3 also. This is since, even though constant names differ (e.g. INTER_LINEAR vs CV_INTER_LINEAR), constant values remain the same(2). So functions accepting integer const values should behave no different in OpenCV 2 and 3. Same is the case for other constants also. This way you just have to change header paths between OpenCV 2 and 3.

OLD ANSWER:- This is not possible. OpenCV 3 is not completely backward compatible with OpenCV 2. You will have to change enums, header paths etc between OpenCV 2 and 3. See Changelog(3) for sections about backward compatibility.

You could try things like copying headers around, giving numbers instead of constant names, using #ifdefs all over your code - but sooner or later that is going to fail. I suggest maintaining separate copies and have peace of mind. I would rather ignore OpenCV 2 altogether unless I am currently in production.

like image 5
kiranpradeep Avatar answered Oct 28 '22 18:10

kiranpradeep