kernel vs user-space audio device driver on macOS

Question

I'm in a need to develop an audio device driver for System Audio Capture(based on Soundflower).
But soon a problem appeared that it seems IOAudioFamily stack is being deprecated in OSX 10.10 and later.
Looking through the IOAudioDevice and IOAudioEngine header files it seems that apple recommends now using the <CoreAudio/AudioServerPlugIn.h> API which runs in user-space. But I can't find lots of information on this user-space device drivers topic. It seems that the only resource is the Apple provided sample devices from https://developer.apple.com/library/prerelease/content/samplecode/AudioDriverExamples/Introduction/Intro.html
Looking through the examples I find that its a lot harder and more work to develop a user-space driver instead of I/O Kit kernel based.
So the question arises what should motivate to develop a device driver in user-space instead of kernel space?

Answer 1

The "SimpleAudioDriver" example is somewhat misnamed. It demonstrates pretty much every feature of the API. This is handy as a reference if you actually need to use those features. It's also structured in a way that's maybe a little more complicated than necessary.

For a virtual device, the NullAudioDriver is probably a much better base, and much, much easier to understand (single source file, if I remember correctly). SimpleAudioDriver is more useful for dealing with issues such as hotplugging, multiple instances of identical devices, etc.

IOAudioEngine is deprecated as you say, and has been since OS X 10.10. Expect it to go away eventually, so if you build your driver with it, you'll probably need to rewrite it sooner than if you create a Core Audio Server Plugin based one.

Testing and debugging audio drivers is awkward either way (due to being so time sensitive), but I'd say userspace ones are slightly less frustrating to deal with. You'll still want to test on a different machine than your development Mac, because if coreaudiod crashes or hangs, apps usually start locking up too, so being able to just ssh in, delete your plugin and kill coreaudiod is handy. Certainly quicker turnaround than having to reboot.

(FWIW, I've shipped both kernel and userspace OS X audio drivers, and I spend a lot of time working on kexts.)