Json only web application. What are the cons? (or Pros)

Question

I want to design a web application whose only interface is json i.e. all the http requests receive responses only in json format and dont render any html on the server side. All the form posts convert the form data into a json object and then post it as a string. All the rendering is done by client side javascript.

The one downside of this approach I know is that browsers without javascript wont be able to do much with this architecture but the interaction on the site is rich enough to be useless to non-javascript browsers anyway.

Are there any other downsides of this approach of designing a web application?

Answer 1

It's an increasingly-common pattern, with tools such as GWT and ext-js. Complex web apps such as GMail have been over 90% JS-created DOM for some time. If you are developing a traditional 'journal' type website with mainly written content to be read this approach will be overkill. But for a complex app that wishes to avoid page refreshes it may well be appropriate.

One downside is that not only does it require a browser that supports JavaScript, it is also easy for the computing resources required by the app to creep up to the point where it needs quite a powerful browser. If you develop in Chrome on a top-end PC you might come to run the app on a less powerful machine such as a netbook or mobile device and find it has become quite sluggish.

Another downside is you lose the opportunity to use HTML tools when working on your pages, and that viewing your application's pages' DOM trees under Firebug or Chrome Developer Tools may be hard work because the relationship between the elements and your code may not be clear.

Edit: another thing to consider is that it is more work to make pages more accessible, as keyboard shortcuts may have to be added (you may not be able to use the browser built in behavior here) and users with special needs may find it more difficult to vary the appearance of the app, for instance by increasing font size.

Another edit: it's unlikely now text content on your website will be successfully crawled by search engines. For this reason you sometimes see server created text-only pages representing the same content, that refer browsers to the JS-enabled version of the page.