Is it OK to call pthread_exit from main?

Question

When I call pthread_exit from main, the program never gets to terminate. I expected the program to finish, since I was exiting the program's only thread, but it doesn't work. It seems hung.

#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <pthread.h>

int main(int argc, char *argv[])
{
    printf("-one-\n");

    pthread_exit(NULL);

    printf("-two-\n");
}

Process Explorer shows that the (only) thread is in Wait:DelayExecution state.

According to pthread_exit documentation:

The process shall exit with an exit status of 0 after the last thread has been terminated. The behavior shall be as if the implementation called exit() with a zero argument at thread termination time.

I'm using Dev-C++ v4.9.9.2 and pthreads-win32 v2.8.0.0 (linking against libpthreadGC2.a).

The library seems to be OK (for example, calling pthread_self or pthread_create from main works fine).

Is there any reason for what I'm not supposed to call pthread_exit from main?

Answer 1

Well its definately legal in the linux implementation of pthreads, see the notes section in pthreads_exit. It states

To allow other threads to continue execution, the main thread should terminate by calling pthread_exit() rather than exit(3).

Further, a look at the source code here (torwads the end) shows that it roughly translates to _endthread or _endthreadex. The documentation here for those makes no mention of not calling it in the initial thread.

Answer 2

This completely legal and intended behavior. The whole process only ends when either all threads terminate or exit is called explicitly or implicitly.

A normal return from main is equivalent to a call to exit. If you end main with pthread_exit your are saying explicitly that you want the other threads to continue.

Answer 3

It's fine to use pthread_exit in main. When pthread_exit is used, the main thread will stop executing and will remain in zombie(defunct) status until all other threads exit.

If you are using pthread_exit in main thread, cannot get return status of other threads and cannot do clean-up for other threads (could be done using pthread_join(3)). Also, it's better to detach threads(pthread_detach(3)) so that thread resources are automatically released on thread termination. The shared resources will not be released until all threads exit.

Its ok to use when not allocating resources in the main thread, clean-up is not needed. Below code shows using pthread_exit in the main thread. The second printf in main is not printed as main thread exits after calling pthread_exit. Ps output shows the defunct main thread.

#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <pthread.h>
#include <unistd.h>
#include <errno.h>

void *functionC(void *);

int main()
{
        int rc;
        pthread_t th;

        if(rc = pthread_create(&th, NULL, &functionC, NULL))
        {
                printf("Thread creation failed, return code %d, errno %d", rc,                 errno);
        }

        printf("Main thread %lu: Sleeping for 20 seconds\n", pthread_self());
        fflush(stdout);
        sleep(20);
        pthread_exit(NULL);
        printf("Main thread %lu: This will not be printed as we already called         pthread_exit\n", pthread_self());
        exit(0);
}

void *functionC(void *)
{
        printf("Thread %lu: Sleeping for 20 second\n", pthread_self());
        sleep(20);
        printf("Thread %lu: Came out of first and sleeping again\n", pthread_self());
        sleep(20);
        printf("CThread %lu: Came out of second sleep\n", pthread_self());
}

Output of the above code:

Main thread 140166909204288: Sleeping for 20 seconds
Thread 140166900684544: Sleeping for 20 second
Thread 140166900684544: Came out of first and sleeping again
CThread 140166900684544: Came out of second sleep

ps output:

root@xxxx-VirtualBox:~/pthread_tst# ps -elfT |grep a.out
0 S root      9530  9530  9496  0  80   0 -  3722 hrtime 17:31 pts/1    00:00:00 ./a.out
1 S root      9530  9531  9496  0  80   0 -  3722 hrtime 17:31 pts/1    00:00:00 ./a.out
0 S root      9537  9537  2182  0  80   0 -  5384 pipe_w 17:31 pts/0    00:00:00 grep --color=auto a.out

root@xxxx-VirtualBox:~/pthread_tst# ps -elfT |grep a.out
0 Z root      9530  9530  9496  0  80   0 -     0 -      17:31 pts/1    00:00:00 [a.out] <defunct>
1 S root      9530  9531  9496  0  80   0 -  4258 hrtime 17:31 pts/1    00:00:00 ./a.out
0 S root      9539  9539  2182  0  80   0 -  5384 pipe_w 17:31 pts/0    00:00:00 grep     --color=auto a.out`

Please check blog Tech Easy for more information on threads.