Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

How to migrate a PostgreSQL database into a SQLServer one?

I have a PostgreSQL database that I want to move to SQL Server -- both schema and data. I am poor so I don't want to pay any money. I am also lazy, so I don't want to do very much work. Currently I'm doing this table by table, and there are about 100 tables to do. This is extremely tedious.

Is there some sort of trick that does what I want?

like image 876
Hut8 Avatar asked Jul 03 '11 15:07

Hut8


People also ask

Can I use PostgreSQL in SQL Server?

PostgreSQL, like many other relational databases, has added support for JSON data, the most common format for semi-structured data stored in NoSQL systems. But because SQL is the only way to interact with a PostgreSQL database, it should not be considered NoSQL.

Is SQL Server better than PostgreSQL?

From the above comparisons, PostgreSQL trumps SQL Server in several scenarios. Not only is it open-source and free, but it also has several features that are easily available and can be implemented automatically, unlike Microsoft SQL Server. Moreover, PostgreSQL has a more suitable concurrency management system.


1 Answers

You should be able to find some useful information in the accepted answer in this Serverfault page: https://serverfault.com/questions/65407/best-tool-to-migrate-a-postgresql-database-to-ms-sql-2005.

If you can get the schema converted without the data, you may be able to shorten the steps for the data by using this command:

pg_dump --data-only --column-inserts your_db_name > data_load_script.sql 

This load will be quite slow, but the --column-inserts option generates the most generic INSERT statements possible for each row of data and should be compatible.

EDIT: Suggestions on converting the schema follows:

I would start by dumping the schema, but removing anything that has to do with ownership or permissions. This should be enough:

pg_dump --schema-only --no-owner --no-privileges your_db_name > schema_create_script.sql 

Edit this file to add the line BEGIN TRANSACTION; to the beginning and ROLLBACK TRANSACTION; to the end. Now you can load it and run it in a query window in SQL Server. If you get any errors, make sure you go to the bottom of the file, highlight the ROLLBACK statement and run it (by hitting F5 while the statement is highlighted).

Basically, you have to resolve each error until the script runs through cleanly. Then you can change the ROLLBACK TRANSACTION to COMMIT TRANSACTION and run one final time.

Unfortunately, I cannot help with which errors you may see as I have never gone from PostgreSQL to SQL Server, only the other way around. Some things that I would expect to be an issue, however (obviously, NOT an exhaustive list):

  • PostgreSQL does auto-increment fields by linking a NOT NULL INTEGER field to a SEQUENCE using a DEFAULT. In SQL Server, this is an IDENTITY column, but they're not exactly the same thing. I'm not sure if they are equivalent, but if your original schema is full of "id" fields, you may be in for some trouble. I don't know if SQL Server has CREATE SEQUENCE, so you may have to remove those.
  • Database functions / Stored Procedures do not translate between RDBMS platforms. You'll need to remove any CREATE FUNCTION statements and translate the algorithms manually.
  • Be careful about encoding of the data file. I'm a Linux person, so I have no idea how to verify encoding in Windows, but you need to make sure that what SQL Server expects is the same as the file you are importing from PostgreSQL. pg_dump has an option --encoding= that will let you set a specific encoding. I seem to recall that Windows tends to use two-byte, UTF-16 encoding for Unicode where PostgreSQL uses UTF-8. I had some issue going from SQL Server to PostgreSQL due to UTF-16 output so it would be worth researching.
  • The PostgreSQL datatype TEXT is simply a VARCHAR without a max length. In SQL Server, TEXT is... complicated (and deprecated). Each field in your original schema that are declared as TEXT will need to be reviewed for an appropriate SQL Server data type.
  • SQL Server has extra data types for UNICODE data. I'm not familiar enough with it to make suggestions. I'm just pointing out that it may be an issue.
like image 82
Matthew Wood Avatar answered Oct 08 '22 08:10

Matthew Wood