Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

how std::thread constructor detects rvalue reference?

Obviously it is possible to pass an rvalue reference to std::thread constructor. My problem is with definition of this constructor in cppreference. It says that this constructor:

template< class Function, class... Args >
explicit thread( Function&& f, Args&&... args );

Creates new std::thread object and associates it with a thread of execution. First the constructor copies/moves all arguments (both the function object f and all args...) to thread-accessible storage as if by the function:

template <class T>
typename decay<T>::type decay_copy(T&& v) {
    return std::forward<T>(v);
}

As far as I can check:

std::is_same<int, std::decay<int&&>::type>::value

returns true. This means std::decay<T>::type will drop rvalue reference part of argument. Then how std::thread constructor knows that which argument is passed by lvalue or rvalue references? Because all T& and T&& will be converted to T by std::decay<T>::type

like image 501
Majid Azimi Avatar asked Feb 07 '23 00:02

Majid Azimi


2 Answers

The std::thread constructor knows the value category of its arguments, because it knows what Function and Args... are, which it uses to perfectly forward the its parameters to decay_copy (or equivalent).

The actual thread function doesn't know the value category. It's always invoked as an rvalue, with all rvalue arguments - which makes sense: the copies of f and args... are local to the thread, and won't be used anywhere else.

like image 141
T.C. Avatar answered Feb 15 '23 07:02

T.C.


auto s = std::decay_copy(std::string("hello"));

Is equivalent to:

template<>
std::string std::decay_copy<std::string>(std::string&& src) {
    return std::string(std::move(src));
}

std::string s = decay_copy<std::string>(std::string("hello"));
like image 33
Richard Hodges Avatar answered Feb 15 '23 09:02

Richard Hodges