Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

How is Coq's parser implemented?

Tags:

parsing

coq

I was entirely amazed by how Coq's parser is implemented. e.g.

https://softwarefoundations.cis.upenn.edu/lf-current/Imp.html#lab347

It's so crazy that the parser seems ok to take any lexeme by giving notation command and subsequent parser is able to parse any expression as it is. So what it means is the grammar must be context sensitive. But this is so flexible that it absolutely goes beyond my comprehension.

Any pointers on how this kind of parser is theoretically feasible? How should it work? Any materials or knowledge would work. I just try to learn about this type of parser in general. Thanks.

Please do not ask me to read Coq's source myself. I want to check the idea in general but not a specific implementation.

like image 628
Jason Hu Avatar asked Apr 03 '17 12:04

Jason Hu


1 Answers

I'll drop my two cents to complement @Zimmi48's excellent answer.

Coq indeed features an extensible parser, which TTBOMK is mainly the work of Hugo Herbelin, built on the CAMLP4/CAMLP5 extensible parsing system by Daniel de Rauglaudre. Both are the canonical sources for information about the parser, I'll try to summarize what I know but note indeed that my experience with the system is short.

The CAMLPX system basically supports any LL1 grammar. Coq exposes to the user the whole set of grammar rules, allowing the user to redefine them. This is the base mechanism on which extensible grammars are built. Notations are compiled into parsing rules in the Metasyntax module, and unfolded in a latter post-processing phase. And that really is AFAICT.

The system itself hasn't changed much in the whole 8.x series, @Zimmi48's comments are more related to the internal processing of commands after parsing. I recently learned that Coq v7 had an even more powerful system for modifying the parser.

In words of Hugo Herbelin "the art of extensible parsing is a delicate one" and indeed it is, but Coq's achieved a pretty great implementation of it.

like image 163
ejgallego Avatar answered Sep 27 '22 16:09

ejgallego