Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

How do you unit test private methods?

I'm building a class library that will have some public & private methods. I want to be able to unit test the private methods (mostly while developing, but also it could be useful for future refactoring).

What is the correct way to do this?

like image 872
Eric Labashosky Avatar asked Oct 30 '08 15:10

Eric Labashosky


People also ask

How do you test private methods in unit testing?

To test private methods, you just need to test the public methods that call them. Call your public method and make assertions about the result or the state of the object. If the tests pass, you know your private methods are working correctly.

How do you cover a private method in a test class?

Use the TestVisible annotation to allow test methods to access private or protected members of another class outside the test class. These members include methods, member variables, and inner classes. This annotation enables a more permissive access level for running tests only.

Can we test private methods in unit testing yes or no?

Yes I do test private functions, because although they are tested by your public methods, it is nice in TDD (Test Driven Design) to test the smallest part of the application. But private functions are not accessible when you are in your test unit class.


1 Answers

If you want to unit test a private method, something may be wrong. Unit tests are (generally speaking) meant to test the interface of a class, meaning its public (and protected) methods. You can of course "hack" a solution to this (even if just by making the methods public), but you may also want to consider:

  1. If the method you'd like to test is really worth testing, it may be worth to move it into its own class.
  2. Add more tests to the public methods that call the private method, testing the private method's functionality. (As the commentators indicated, you should only do this if these private methods's functionality is really a part in with the public interface. If they actually perform functions that are hidden from the user (i.e. the unit test), this is probably bad).
like image 105
Jeroen Heijmans Avatar answered Oct 03 '22 20:10

Jeroen Heijmans