Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

How can I determine the quality of a connection in iOS?

Tags:

ios

I'm familiar with using Reachability to determine the type of internet connection (if any) being used on an iOS device. Unfortunately that's not a decent indicator of connection quality. Wifi with low signal strength is pretty sketchy and 3G with anything less than 3 bars is a disaster (not to mention networks that only allow EDGE connections).

How can I determine the quality of my connection so I can help my users decide if they should be downloading larger files on their current connection?

like image 784
Nick Avatar asked Dec 07 '11 17:12

Nick


2 Answers

A pragmatic approach would be to download one moderately large-sized file hosted on a reliable, worldwide CDN, at the start of your application. You know the filesize beforehand, you just have to measure the time it takes, make a simple computation and then you've got your estimate of the quality of the connection.

For example, jQuery UI source code, unminified, gzipped weighs roughly 90kB. Downloading it from http://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jqueryui/1.8.14/jquery-ui.js takes 327ms here on my Mac. So one can assume I have at least a decent connection that can handle approximately 300kB/s (and in fact, it can handle much more).

The trick is to find the good balance between the original file size and the latency of the network, as the full download speed is never reached on a small file like this. On the other hand, downloading 1MB right after launching your application will surely penalize most of your users, even if it will allow you to measure more precisely the speed of the connection.

like image 143
Cyrille Avatar answered Sep 20 '22 13:09

Cyrille


Cyrille's answer is a good pragmatic answer, but is not really in the end a great solution in the mobile context for these reasons:

  • It involves doing a test "at the start of your application" by which I assume he means when your app launches. But your app may execute for a long while, may go background and then back into the foreground, and all the while the user is changing network contexts with changes in underlying network performance - so that initial test result may bear no relationship to the "current" performance of the network connection.
  • For the reason he rightly points out, that it is "penalizing" your user by making them download a test file over what may already be constrained network conditions.

You also suggest in your original post that you want your user to decide if they should download based on information you present to them. But I would suggest that this is not a good way to approach interacting with mobile users - that you should not be asking them to make complicated decisions. If absolutely necessary, only ask if they want to download the file if you think it may present a problem, but keep it that simple - "Do you want to download XYZ file (100 MB)?" I personally would even avoid even that.

Instead of downloading a test file, the better solution is to monitor and adapt. Measure the performance of the connection as you go along, keep track of the "freshness" of that information you have about how well the connection is performing, and only present your user with a decision to make if based on the on-going performance of the connection it seems necessary.

EDIT: For example, if you determine a patience threshold that in your opinion represents tolerable download performance, keep track of each download that the user does in order to determine if that threshold is being reached. That way, instead of clogging up the users connection with test downloads, you're using the real world activity as the determining factor for "quality of the connection", which is ultimately about the end-user experience of the quality of the connection. If you decide to provide the user with the ability to cancel downloads, then you have an excellent "input" about the user's actual patience threshold, and can adapt your functionality to that situation, by subsequently giving them the choice before they start the download. If you've flipped into this type of "confirmation" mode, but then find that files are starting to download faster, you could dynamically exit the confirmation mode.

like image 35
Rob Reuss Avatar answered Sep 20 '22 13:09

Rob Reuss