Haskell: Constrain function on type Double to only work with Integers

Question

Suppose I'm writing a function that takes a list of integers and returns only those integers in the list that are less than 5.2. I might do something like this:

belowThreshold = filter (< 5.2)

Easy enough, right? But now I want to constrain this function to only work with input lists of type [Int] for design reasons of my own. This seems like a reasonable request. Alas, no. A declaration that constraints the types as so:

belowThreshold :: [Integer] -> [Integer]
belowThreshold = filter (< 5.2)

Causes a type error. So what's the story here? Why does doing filter (< 5.2) seem to convert my input list into Doubles? How can I make a version of this function that only accepts integer lists and only returns integer lists? Why does the type system hate me?

Answer 1

Check the inferred type of belowThreshold in ghci before adding your annoatation:

> :t belowThreshold
belowThreshold :: [Double] -> [Double]

It sounds like you expected Num a => [a] -> [a] when you said "constrain this function". You are actually changing the type of the function when you add the [Integer] -> [Integer] annotation.

To make this work, use an explicit conversion:

belowThreshold = filter ((< 5.2) . fromIntegral)

Now belowThreshold :: [Integer] -> [Integer] like you wanted. But the integers are converted to doubles before comparison to 5.2.

So why do you need the conversion? The type error probably misled you: the list of Integers wasn't being converted to Doubles by comparison to 5.2, the real problem is that only Doubles can be compared to Doubles, so you must pass a list of Doubles to belowThreshold. Haskell has no implicit conversions, not even between numbers. If you want conversions, you have to write them yourself.

I want to constrain this function to only work with input lists of type [Int] for design reasons of my own. This seems like a reasonable request.

Well, from the perspective of the type system, no. Is this reasonable code?

'c' < "foo"

What about this?

12 < "bar"

All of these values are instances of Ord, but you can't use them together with (<). Haskell has no implicit conversions. So even if two values are both instances of Num as well as Ord, you won't be able to compare them with (<) if they are of different types.

Answer 2

You are trying to compare an Integer to a double (5.2). Haskell doesn't like that. Try using

filter (< 6)