Good or bad practice for Dialogs in wpf with MVVM?

Question

This is a good approach and I used similar ones in the past. Go for it!

One minor thing I'd definitely do is make the event receive a boolean for when you need to set "false" in the DialogResult.

event EventHandler<RequestCloseEventArgs> RequestCloseDialog;

and the EventArgs class:

public class RequestCloseEventArgs : EventArgs
{
    public RequestCloseEventArgs(bool dialogResult)
    {
        this.DialogResult = dialogResult;
    }

    public bool DialogResult { get; private set; }
}

I've been using an almost identical approach for several months now, and I'm very happy with it (i.e. I haven't yet felt the urge to rewrite it completely...)

In my implementation, I use a IDialogViewModel that exposes things such as the title, the standad buttons to show (in order to have a consistent apparence across all dialogs), a RequestClose event, and a few other things to be able to control the window size and behavior

If you are talking about dialogue windows and not just about the pop-up message boxes, please consider my approach below. The key points are:

1. I pass a reference to Module Controller into the constructor of each ViewModel (you can use injection).
2. That Module Controller has public/internal methods for creating dialogue windows (just creating, without returning a result). Hence to open a dialogue window in ViewModel I write: controller.OpenDialogEntity(bla, bla...)
3. Each dialogue window notifies about its result (like OK, Save, Cancel, etc.) via Weak Events. If you use PRISM, then it's easier to publish notifications using this EventAggregator.
4. To handle dialogue results, I'm using subscription to notifications (again Weak Events and EventAggregator in case of PRISM). To reduce dependency on such notifications, use independent classes with standard notifications.

Pros:

• Less code. I don't mind using interfaces, but I've seen too many projects where excessiveness of using interfaces and abstraction layers cause more trouble than help.
• Open dialogue windows through Module Controller is a simple way to avoid strong references and still allows to use mock-ups for testing.
• Notification through weak events reduce number of potential memory leaks.

Cons:

• Not easy to distinguish required notification from others in the handler. Two solutions:
  • send a unique token on opening a dialogue window and check that token in the subscription
  • use generic notification classes <T> where T is enumeration of entities (or for simplicity it can be type of ViewModel).
• For a project should be an agreement about using notification classes to prevent duplicating them.
• For enormously large projects the Module Controller can be overwhelmed by methods for creating windows. In this case it's better to split it up in several modules.

P.S. I have been using this approach for quite a long time now and ready to defend its eligibility in comments and provide some examples if required.