Logo Questions Linux Laravel Mysql Ubuntu Git Menu
 

Find CURRENTLY selected <option> with XPath

Tags:

dom

xpath

What's the correct XPath syntax to check if an option element is currently selected, or just to get the selected option element from a select element, on an open page with which the user, and JavaScript, may have interacted? Is this even possible with XPath, or does it lack the ability to look at DOM properties?

I can't find any documentation on this, and have (speculatively) tried:

  • //option[@selected=true]
  • //option[@selected="selected"]
  • //option[@selected]

but none of these work; they simply don't match any elements.

(In case it matters, I've tried this both using the $x function in the Chrome developer console, and using the find_elements_by_xpath method in Selenium for Python.)

like image 953
Mark Amery Avatar asked Apr 02 '13 16:04

Mark Amery


1 Answers

Short answer: it's not possible.

Longer answer: XPath can look at HTML attributes, but it can't look at DOM properties. Selecting an <option> element in a <select> changes the selected property of the <option> to true, and also changes the value property of its parent <select> element, but it doesn't affect the attributes of either, so it is invisible to XPath.

To find <option> elements that have the selected attribute set, which is often how a page author might determine which option is initially selected, you can use //option[@selected]. But this does not find the currently selected <option>; changes that the user makes to the selection are invisible to XPath. There's no guarantee it will even find the initially selected option, since it's possible that the page author didn't put the selected attribute on any elements and either let the browser select the first option by default or had some JavaScript select the initial option via the selected property.

The multiple other answers here claiming that a selector like //option[@selected] can detect selection changes made by the user after the page loads are simply completely wrong.

Of course, if you're able to use CSS selectors instead of XPath selectors, then option:checked will do the job.

like image 156
Mark Amery Avatar answered Oct 13 '22 14:10

Mark Amery