Fastest, leanest way to append characters to form a string in Swift

Question

I come from a C# background where System.String is immutable and string concatenation is relatively expensive (as it requires reallocating the string) we know to use the StringBuilder type instead as it preallocates a larger buffer where single characters (Char, a 16-bit value-type) and short strings can be concatenated cheaply without extra allocation.

I'm porting some C# code to Swift which reads from a bit-array ([Bool]) at sub-octet indexes with character lengths less than 8 bits (it's a very space-conscious file format).

My C# code does something like this:

 StringBuilder sb = new StringBuilder( expectedCharacterCount );  int idxInBits = 0;  Boolean[] bits = ...;  for(int i = 0; i < someLength; i++) {      Char c = ReadNextCharacter( ref idxInBits, 6 ); // each character is 6 bits in this example      sb.Append( c );  } 

In Swift, I assume NSMutableString is the equivalent of .NET's StringBuilder, and I found this QA about appending individual characters ( How to append a character to string in Swift? ) so in Swift I have this:

var buffer: NSMutableString for i in 0..<charCount {     let charValue: Character = readNextCharacter( ... )     buffer.AppendWithFormat("%c", charValue) } return String(buffer) 

But I don't know why it goes through a format-string first, that seems inefficient (reparsing the format-string on every iteration) and as my code is running on iOS devices I want to be very conservative with my program's CPU and memory usage.

As I was writing this, I learned my code should really be using UnicodeScalar instead of Character, problem is NSMutableString does not let you append a UnicodeScalar value, you have to use Swift's own mutable String type, so now my code looks like:

var buffer: String for i in 0..<charCount {     let x: UnicodeScalar = readNextCharacter( ... )     buffer.append(x) } return buffer 

I thought that String was immutable, but I noticed its append method returns Void.

I still feel uncomfortable doing this because I don't know how Swift's String type is implemented internally, and I don't see how I can preallocate a large buffer to avoid reallocations (assuming Swift's String uses a growing algorithm).

Answer 1

(This answer was written based on documentation and source code valid for Swift 2 and 3: possibly needs updates and amendments once Swift 4 arrives)

Since Swift is now open-source, we can actually have a look at the source code for Swift:s native String

• swift/stdlib/public/core/String.swift

From the source above, we have following comment

/// Growth and Capacity /// =================== /// /// When a string's contiguous storage fills up, new storage must be /// allocated and characters must be moved to the new storage. /// `String` uses an exponential growth strategy that makes `append` a /// constant time operation *when amortized over many invocations*. 

Given the above, you shouldn't need to worry about the performance of appending characters in Swift (be it via append(_: Character), append(_: UniodeScalar) or appendContentsOf(_: String)), as reallocation of the contiguous storage for a certain String instance should not be very frequent w.r.t. number of single characters needed to be appended for this re-allocation to occur.

Also note that NSMutableString is not "purely native" Swift, but belong to the family of bridged Obj-C classes (accessible via Foundation).

---

A note to your comment

"I thought that String was immutable, but I noticed its append method returns Void."

String is just a (value) type, that may be used by mutable as well as immutable properties

var foo = "foo" // mutable  let bar = "bar" // immutable     /* (both the above inferred to be of type 'String') */ 

The mutating void-return instance methods append(_: Character) and append(_: UniodeScalar) are accessible to mutable as well as immutable String instances, but naturally using them with the latter will yield a compile time error

let chars : [Character]  = ["b","a","r"] foo.append(chars[0]) // "foob" bar.append(chars[0]) // error: cannot use mutating member on immutable value ...