Equals method for data class in Kotlin

Question

I have the following data class

data class PuzzleBoard(val board: IntArray) {     val dimension by lazy { Math.sqrt(board.size.toDouble()).toInt() } } 

I read that data classes in Kotlin get equals()/hashcode() method for free.

I instantiated two objects.

val board1 = PuzzleBoard(intArrayOf(1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,0)) val board2 = PuzzleBoard(intArrayOf(1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,0)) 

But still, the following statements return false.

board1 == board2 board1.equals(board2) 

Answer 1

In Kotlin data classes equality check, arrays, just like other classes, are compared using equals(...), which compares the arrays references, not the content. This behavior is described here:

So, whenever you say

• arr1 == arr2

• DataClass(arr1) == DataClass(arr2)

• ...

you get the arrays compared through equals(), i.e. referentially.

Given that,

val arr1 = intArrayOf(1, 2, 3) val arr2 = intArrayOf(1, 2, 3)  println(arr1 == arr2) // false is expected here println(PuzzleBoard(arr1) == PuzzleBoard(arr2)) // false too 

---

To override this and have the arrays compared structurally, you can implement equals(...)+hashCode() in your data class using Arrays.equals(...) and Arrays.hashCode(...):

override fun equals(other: Any?): Boolean{     if (this === other) return true     if (other?.javaClass != javaClass) return false      other as PuzzleBoard      if (!Arrays.equals(board, other.board)) return false      return true }  override fun hashCode(): Int{     return Arrays.hashCode(board) } 

^{This code is what IntelliJ IDEA can automatically generate for non-data classes.}

Another solution is to use List<Int> instead of IntArray. Lists are compared structurally, so that you won't need to override anything.