Django filter versus get for single object?

Question

get() is provided specifically for this case. Use it.

Option 2 is almost precisely how the get() method is actually implemented in Django, so there should be no "performance" difference (and the fact that you're thinking about it indicates you're violating one of the cardinal rules of programming, namely trying to optimize code before it's even been written and profiled -- until you have the code and can run it, you don't know how it will perform, and trying to optimize before then is a path of pain).

You can install a module called django-annoying and then do this:

from annoying.functions import get_object_or_None

obj = get_object_or_None(MyModel, id=1)

if not obj:
    #omg the object was not found do some error stuff

1 is correct. In Python an exception has equal overhead to a return. For a simplified proof you can look at this.

2 This is what Django is doing in the backend. get calls filter and raises an exception if no item is found or if more than one object is found.

I'm a bit late to the party, but with Django 1.6 there is the first() method on querysets.

https://docs.djangoproject.com/en/dev/ref/models/querysets/#django.db.models.query.QuerySet.first

---

Returns the first object matched by the queryset, or None if there is no matching object. If the QuerySet has no ordering defined, then the queryset is automatically ordered by the primary key.

Example:

p = Article.objects.order_by('title', 'pub_date').first()
Note that first() is a convenience method, the following code sample is equivalent to the above example:

try:
    p = Article.objects.order_by('title', 'pub_date')[0]
except IndexError:
    p = None

Why do all that work? Replace 4 lines with 1 builtin shortcut. (This does its own try/except.)

from django.shortcuts import get_object_or_404

obj = get_object_or_404(MyModel, id=1)

I can't speak with any experience of Django but option #1 clearly tells the system that you are asking for 1 object, whereas the second option does not. This means that option #1 could more easily take advantage of cache or database indexes, especially where the attribute you're filtering on is not guaranteed to be unique.

Also (again, speculating) the second option may have to create some sort of results collection or iterator object since the filter() call could normally return many rows. You'd bypass this with get().

Finally, the first option is both shorter and omits the extra temporary variable - only a minor difference but every little helps.

Some more info about exceptions. If they are not raised, they cost almost nothing. Thus if you know you are probably going to have a result, use the exception, since using a conditional expression you pay the cost of checking every time, no matter what. On the other hand, they cost a bit more than a conditional expression when they are raised, so if you expect not to have a result with some frequency (say, 30% of the time, if memory serves), the conditional check turns out to be a bit cheaper.

But this is Django's ORM, and probably the round-trip to the database, or even a cached result, is likely to dominate the performance characteristics, so favor readability, in this case, since you expect exactly one result, use get().