Character Animation with Metal

Question

I have just delved into the world of Metal, and I thought that I'd got the hang of it! But then it occurred to me that if I wanted to make a game, then static objects moving around a screen wouldn't suffice. So my question is, 'Is it possible to create animations for models with Metal?'

I have looked at using other APIs, such as SpriteKit, and SceneKit, but I found that they do not support shaders, and are not as powerful as Metal.

The only way that I can think about how I would go about this, is by creating 60 different models, and then loading each one one after the other, to give a 'stop-motion' kind of effect, but I think that this would probably be incredibly inefficient, and was hoping that there was an easier answer?

Thanks a lot!

Answer 1

Yes, there are other, more efficient ways to do animation. But before getting into that, a warning: it really looks like you're barking up the wrong tree here.

Metal is a (conceptually) very low-level interface. You use Metal to talk (almost) directly to the GPU, so to work with it you need to think (sort of) like a GPU: in terms of data buffers, vertex transformations, etc. You seem to be working at a much higher conceptual level, so you're probably better served by one of the high-level game engines: SpriteKit for 2D or SceneKit for 3D. (Or a third party engine like Cocos or Unity.) Metal, on the other hand, is better suited for building those game engines.

SpriteKit and SceneKit do support shaders. Look at SKShader and SCNShadable in the docs (and be sure to click the "More" links to read the full overviews). SceneKit also supports character animations (aka skeletal animation aka skinning): typically one designs and rigs a model for animation in an external authoring tool (Maya, Blender, etc), then uses SceneKit to work with the animations at run time.

It is possible to do things like GPU-based skeletal animation in Metal. But I haven't seen any tutorials or similar written about it yet, probably because Metal is such a new technology. Fundamentally, though, it'd be based on the same sorts of techniques you'd use for skeletal animation in OpenGL or Direct3D — and much has been written about animation for those technologies. If you're willing to invest the time and energy to work at a low level, adapting the subject matter from GL/D3D tutorials is relatively easy.